Skip to main content
Get our mobile app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Acre Traffic Court Ruling

Driver's Siren Excuse Fails to Lift Conviction

An Israeli court ruled that wartime security conditions do not excuse holding a phone while driving and rejected the motorist's bid to reopen his case.

Alert

An Israeli court has refused to overturn the conviction of a driver caught holding his mobile phone at the wheel in Acre. The man had argued he was checking Home Front Command alerts during an air raid siren. Details of the decision were reported on Monday.

The driver, who was convicted in absentia, said the security situation at the time justified his actions. The judge disagreed and ruled that wartime conditions do not exempt drivers from responsibility for the offense.

The case began with a traffic ticket issued to the driver in Acre during the war. According to the driver, a siren sounded at the time and hundreds of vehicles were stuck in a long traffic jam near a traffic light. He said traffic came to a complete halt for more than half an hour. He said he picked up his phone to see where the Home Front Command, the Israeli military body responsible for civilian alerts, was reporting sirens, so he could choose a safe route home.

He also said he had not been on a call at all, since phone calls in his car go through the vehicle's multimedia system.

The court was not persuaded. "The applicant does not deny that he held the phone in his hand while driving," the decision stated.

The judge acknowledged the security situation and the fears drivers faced during the war, but said these did not permit holding a phone while driving. "I do not take lightly the feelings that accompanied drivers during the war," she wrote. She ruled that even if traffic had been unusually heavy, that would not justify cancelling the conviction. "These circumstances are, at most, a consideration for leniency in sentencing," she wrote.

Ready for more?

The request to cancel the conviction also addressed why the driver had failed to appear in court in the first place. The original verdict was handed down on October 4, 2026, after he did not attend his hearing. Five days later he filed a request to cancel the ruling. He said he had been ill with a severe flu from October 3 to 5, which left him unable to attend or take part in the hearing. He added that he had also wanted to avoid infecting others.

The state opposed the request. It argued that the driver had been properly summoned and had not shown that his medical condition prevented him from notifying the court of his absence in advance.

The court accepted the state's position. The decision noted that his sick note was issued retroactively and did not explain why he could not appear in court or at least inform the court of his condition. The judge pointed out that although he said the illness began on Saturday, the hearing was held the following day, Sunday, and he did not claim to have tried to contact the court that morning.

"I was not convinced that the applicant's absence stemmed from a justified reason," she ruled.

The state also challenged the driver's account of the traffic jam. It said he had presented no evidence that traffic had come to a complete stop, while police body cameras recorded relatively free-flowing traffic.

The court ultimately rejected the request. It cited both the lack of a satisfactory explanation for his failure to appear and the absence of any justification to reopen the proceedings. The conviction stands, and the stay of sentence granted after he filed his request has been cancelled.

The court also ordered that the 2,000-shekel deposit the driver paid to secure the stay be returned to him, subject to the law. The sum was a deposit, not an additional fine.

The ruling makes clear that exceptional security circumstances may be taken into account when setting a sentence. In this case, however, they did not justify cancelling a conviction for holding a phone while driving.

Ready for more?

Join our newsletter to receive updates on new articles and exclusive content.

We respect your privacy and will never share your information.

Enjoyed this article?

Yes
No
Follow Us:

Unmissable content


Loading comments...

Also of Interest