Skip to main content

Lies

Defense Minister Says No Restrictions on IDF in Lebanon. Soldiers on the Ground Say Otherwise.

IDF Soldiers Contradict Katz: 'We Need Top-Level Approval Just to Act on Terrorists Watching Us'

Israel Katz
Israel Katz (Photo: Flash90)

A stark contradiction has emerged between the official line coming out of Jerusalem and the reality being described by soldiers on the ground in southern Lebanon, casting doubt on Defense Minister Israel Katz's insistence that IDF troops are operating without restrictions.

Katz published a statement Saturday declaring that "there are no restrictions, and there have been no restrictions, on IDF soldiers in Lebanon operating to remove threats," adding that the IDF has responded to attacks with force and that all territorial gains in the security zone are being preserved.

But soldiers stationed on the yellow line are telling a sharply different story. According to multiple accounts from the field, troops are required to obtain approvals at the highest levels of command before they are permitted to act, even against Hezbollah operatives who are actively surveilling their positions or against suspicious movements in their immediate vicinity.

The gap between the two accounts aligns with analysis published by Israeli security correspondents earlier Saturday, who broke down precisely what "threat removal only" means in practice: soldiers can engage a terrorist approaching their position, but cannot strike a command center in Nabatieh or Tyre. They can hit a rocket on its launcher, but not the underground facility in the Bekaa where Hezbollah is producing the next thousand rockets. They can shoot down a drone in flight, but not the Beirut headquarters from which Hezbollah commanders are directing the offensive.

Critics have described Katz's statement as a deliberate attempt to create an alternative reality, arguing that the restrictions, imposed by order of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the defense minister himself, are in fact quite severe.

The situation on the ground is further complicated by Hezbollah's behavior during the pause. The group has publicly stated it will not hesitate to confront any Israeli attempt to seize territory, and field reports indicate Hezbollah operatives are actively tailing and surveilling IDF units, exploiting the constraints soldiers say they are operating under.

For now, Israeli soldiers say they are being watched, and waiting for permission to respond.

Ready for more?

Join our newsletter to receive updates on new articles and exclusive content.

We respect your privacy and will never share your information.