German Rabbi Participates in IDF Course

For the first time: a rabbi from the German army participated in a military rabbis course

In the last military rabbis course, Rabbi Shmuel Havlin also participated, who is the Chief Rabbi of the Northern Command of the German Army. In a conversation with sergeants, he says: "I was very impressed by the way the military rabbinate considers every halachic detail"

Rabbi Havlin in the rabbinic military course

This evening (Wednesday) will mark the conclusion of another cycle of the military rabbis course, in which for the first time in history, a senior officer of the German military also participated. 80 years after the Holocaust and 75 years after the establishment of the state, this combination of words still sounds unbelievable.

Rabbi Shmuel Havlin, a Chabad emissary in the city of Bremen, also serving as the military rabbi of the northern districts in the German Army, including the submarine base in Hamburg where submarines are assembled and sold to Israel.

About three months ago, he visited the country with representatives of the German Army rabbinate, and then he was offered to participate in the military rabbis course. He seized the opportunity and in a conversation with Srugim, he describes the experience he went through during the course, from which he gained a lot of knowledge and many positive thoughts about the thinking of the military rabbinate.

"It was a unique experience," describes Rabbi Havlin. "I participated in this course for three weeks, and it was really successful."

Rabbi Shmuel Havlin

You are considered an officer in the German army, how does it actually work there in a professional army?

"From a military and rabbinical perspective, it's so different than here. First of all, as you mentioned, it's a professional army - so the soldiers aren't always military personnel, but rather what's called "civilian employees of the IDF". They are engineers or professionals who work for the military and go about their civilian lives.

"The second thing that differs is the absolute separation between religion and state. The state there is secular, and they take into consideration the soldiers' beliefs, but there is no connection between the military and religion."

Rabbi Havlin is a Chabad Hasid, a German citizen, who heard that the German Army was looking for military rabbis. In the German Army, there are 10 positions for rabbis (currently 4 are filled), and he is appointed as the rabbi responsible for the northern region of the country - which includes the districts of Hamburg, Bremen, and Holstein.

How many Jewish soldiers are there in the German army?

"The figures are not known to the last detail, because soldiers in the German army do not have to share their faith and declare their religion. We estimate the numbers between 600 and 800."

Out of an army of half a million?

"No, the numbers are lower, around a quarter of a million. I mention again that this is a professional army, and there are few Jews who enlist and choose this position as a profession for life."

And it's impossible to ignore the question of how a Jew can enlist in the German Army, especially after the Holocaust, and sing the anthem "Germany Above All" in formations?

"Obviously, it does something in the heart, but Jews enlist in foreign armies throughout the Western world, and there are military rabbis worldwide. Once again, the majority of Jews who enlist are not combatants but individuals with civilian professions. We come to support them, because wherever there are Jews, there are also religious needs."

Are there orthodox soldiers, or am I really exaggerating now?

"Yes. Not many, but there are some. And we need to deal with a lot of challenges. Think about a soldier who finds himself alone in a remote base at the end of Germany and suddenly demands kosher food – it's quite complex to provide him with the proper meals. So, either we send him ready-made combat rations or we arrange something locally.

"For example, I regularly host a soldier for Shabbat in my community so that he can observe Shabbat and have kosher food."

Considering every detail

Let's go back to the rabbinical course, in fact you were in the religious part, that is, training on how a military rabbi runs the unit in terms of religion.

"Yes, and I want to tell you that I was very impressed by the way the IDF Military Rabbinate considers every detail, even things I hadn't thought about that could be relevant.

"It's true that they have accumulated knowledge over 75 years, with a number of Jewish soldiers that we don't have. And that's impressive. How they organize kitchen certification, with a detailed manual for cleanliness and kashrut. And the regulations regarding eruv, prayer, and synagogues, and how they transport Torah scrolls to the field. From my perspective, it was a truly unique experience.

"Of course, in Germany, we won't be able to utilize all the content, both due to the soldiers and the structure of the army, but there are many things we can integrate and improve, and that was very successful. Perhaps there's one thing that the German Army leads over the IDF, and that's its widespread acknowledgment of the "Shabbat Gentile" concept at every base."

Rabbi Havlin in prayer at the rabbinic military course

Both in the German rabbinate and in the military rabbinate, the rabbi also serves as an address for matters of faith and spiritual conversations. "We are also the address for those interested in Judaism or seeking to delve deeper. People turn to us primarily in cases of family bereavement – regarding assistance with burial and mourning laws, and then sometimes there's also a desire to get to know the tradition and heritage better, which is additional value we can provide."

Cooperation between the military rabbinate and the rabbinate in Germany

Rabbi Havelin underwent the course while he was on 'civilian' status, but despite his distinct appearance, he didn't feel like a stranger among the rest of the soldiers.

"I took part in the course with them, the rabbis' course, which means the weeks during which they deal with topics related to military rabbis, and that was what was relevant for me. After that, when they went on their military training for officer training, I didn't need to participate, and I returned to Germany."

"Now begins the challenging part for me, to summarize all the content I've received, to formulate it, put it in writing, and see how we integrate and incorporate it within our context."

The cooperation between the IDF and the German Army is not new. In recent years, the ties between the militaries have strengthened, with German officers attending courses in the IDF and on Israel's Independence Day flyovers, a German aircraft also participated in the aerial display in the skies of Israel.

The German Air Force plane next to the Israeli Air Force plane above the Knesset (IDF website)

What is the most striking difference you have seen between the German army and the IDF, punctuality?

Germans are known for their precision, but in the IDF, they also adhere to schedules, and that's a good thing. The biggest difference is the structure. Here, it's a people's army where everyone serves for a relatively short period of time. There, it's a professional army where only a portion serves for longer periods.

The motivation was sky high

I also want to highlight the human aspect, the people who were on the course with me. This means a huge group of reservist military rabbis who left their homes for a period of 6 weeks during the summer months. Most of them have families with children at home, and these are the months of the extended vacation.

And with all of this, everything was done with joy and sky high motivation. It's not a simple course – the days began each morning at 6 AM with the morning prayer and ended at 11:00 PM at the training base. Despite the intensity, the motivation was at its peak. It simply impressed me greatly, and I truly enjoyed every moment.

I sincerely thank you from the bottom of my heart for this opportunity to participate in the course, primarily because it's not to be taken for granted, and secondly, the desire to help and to be assisted, because ultimately, assisting the Jewish soldier is in all of our interests.

The military rabbinate is happy about the cooperation

Lieutenant Colonel Aviad Simhoni, a Communication Officer of the IDF Military Rabbinate, added: "Two years ago, a military rabbinate branch was established in the German Army as part of the religious affairs framework of the military. Within this branch, there are several military rabbis in different districts and a chief military rabbi.

The military rabbis, like other religious personnel, are civilians. They do not wear uniforms and are not part of the command structure. The IDF Military Rabbinate has maintained good relations with them, assisting and supporting them extensively, and providing advice primarily on matters of knowledge sharing and developing thought processes."

Around Holocaust Remembrance Day, representatives from the German Army's Military Rabbinate visited Israel and joined tours with the IDF Military Rabbinate. During their visit, the idea emerged that one of their rabbis would participate in the advanced training phase of the IDF Military Rabbinate's rabbinical course, which is currently taking place.

The IDF Military Rabbinate is very pleased with this connection and opportunity, as are the Communication Officers of the IDF, this connection is fruitful and enriches all relevant parties and factors, as they learn from each other and further solidify themselves as part of this relationship.

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Hamas leaders, Qatar

Hamas leaders forced to relocate

The leadership of Hamas have been reportedly kicked out of Qatar amid pressure for a ceasefire deal in Gaza. 

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21:09

Israel-Gaza war, Rafah

Is the IDF's operation in Rafah coming to an end?

IDF Chief Says major progress has been made in destroying Hamas' Rafah Brigade. "We have a very high record in the Rafah battles, and I tell you, I appreciate that very much," Halevi said.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 20:35

Iran, Israel Hezbollah war 

Taliban to take 'joint action' against Israel

As a potential war with Hezbollah in Lebanon brews, Iran and the terror group the Taliban have announced their interest in becoming involved in a war against Israel.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 20:01

Anti-Israel, Pro-Hamas protests

"Appauling" Biden reacts to anti-Israel protest outside synagogue

After violence broke out yesterday when Pro-Palestinian protestors clashed with Pro-Israeli's just outside the Adas Torah synagogue in LA, US president Biden condemns the attack.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 19:15

IDF, Hostage update

After the IDF spokesman's announcement: This is the number of abductees who are not alive

Following the IDF spokesperson's announcement regarding the fall of IDF soldier Muhammad Elatrash in battle, who was defined as a captive, the number of captives identified as deceased has risen to 45.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 18:32

Israel-Gaza War, Hostages

Hamas leaders preparing to leave Qatar - to where?

The National, an English language Emirati paper, reports that Hamas political leaders are planning to leave Qatar rather than yield to American pressure to agree to a hostage deal.

Avi Woolf | 17:47

Israel-Gaza War, Hezbollah

Watch: IDF strikes deep inside Lebanon

The IDF struck Hezbollah aerial defense systems in Baalbek deep inside Lebanon.

Avi Woolf | 17:35

Israel-Gaza War, October 7

Netanyahu to meet survivors of October 7 Hamas attack at Nir Oz

The Prime Minister made this decision after receiving a letter from the residents of Nir Oz beseeching him to understand the experience of being abandoned and defenseless.

Avi Woolf | 17:19

Politics, Netanyahu, Hostage deal

Deal or no deal: backlash following Netanyahu's interview 

Netanyahu sparks controversy as he agrees to hostage deal but not a permanent pause in fighting. Such comments seem to go against the last ceasefire deal accepted by Israel, causing contradictions regarding Israel's exact goals for the war and its potential end. 

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 17:18

Israel-Gaza War, Hostages

GRAPHIC: Video of hostages being taken on October 7

A Hamas video showing the kidnapping of Hersh Goldberg-Polin, Or Levy, and Eliya Cohen was released today with the families' permission.

Avi Woolf | 16:41

IDF Gaza airstrikes, Hamas 

IDF kills senior Hamas operative

A prominent Hamas leader who developed weapons for the terrorist group was killed in a drone strike in the Gaza Strip yesterday, the Israeli military claims.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 16:16

Israel-Gaza War

How many Palestinians have left the Gaza Strip?

The London-based Saudi paper al-Majalla reported that a surprising number of Palestinians have left the Gaza Strip entirely.

JFeed Staff | 16:04