Israel-Gaza War, Hostages

Why Gazan civilians don't reveal the location of Israeli hostages

If Palestinian civilians know where the hostages are, why don't they tell Israel?

Demonstrators call for the release of Israeli hostages held in the Gaza Strip outside Hakirya Base in Tel Aviv, May 8, 2024. (Photo by Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)

The Israel-Palestine conflict is fraught with complexities. Israeli hostages held by militant groups in Gaza create a distressing and complicated scenario that impacts both Israelis and Palestinians.

Although Hamas cynically embeds itself within the civilian population on purpose, it also relies on "uninvolved" Gazan civilians to keep the hostages imprisoned within their own homes, making it easier for Hamas combatants to stay on the move, both in the tunnels and above ground.

Here are some reasons why Palestinians do not tell Israel where our hostages are being held:

1. Fear

Militant groups in Gaza maintain strict control over the region, and dissent is often met with severe punishment. Civilians who cooperate with Israeli forces or reveal sensitive information risk harsh and immediate retaliation against themselves and their families.

2. Decades of Hamas anti-Israel propaganda

There are also many Palestinians who have been radicalized by the indefatigable Hamas propaganda machine. They see the taking of hostages as either a necessary evil or just revenge against their sworn enemies.

3. Mistrust

Years of conflict have bred deep mistrust between Palestinian civilians and Israeli authorities. Many Palestinians view Israel not only as an adversary but also as an occupying force responsible for numerous hardships, including military incursions, blockades, and economic deprivation.

4. Collective responsibility for a national cause

Revealing information about hostages could be perceived as undermining the Palestinian goals of autonomy and recognition.

We acknowledge the possibility that many Palestinian civilians are caught in a moral and ethical dilemma: While they may not support the taking of hostages, the fear of retaliation and the consequences of their actions weigh heavily on their decisions. Additionally, some might hope for a negotiated settlement that could ensure the safe return of hostages without further violence, preferring this uncertain path over immediate disclosure.

Given all of this, it remains extremely unlikely that Palestinian civilians would ever reveal information about where our hostages are being held, necessitating the IDF to ramp up its war efforts if it wants to bring the hostages home.


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Hostage release, ceasefire deal, Israel-Hamas

Proposal: Breakthrough in the dispute over the Hostage Deal

A breakthrough in the Philadelphia Axis issue: Israel, Egypt, and the United States have formulated a proposal to Hamas aimed at resolving the dispute over control of the axis. The IDF conveyed a message to the diplomatic level that they could accommodate such a plan since Hamas lacks the capability to build tunnels.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.07.24

Hostage release, ceasefire deal, Israel-Hamas, Gaza

The Senior Minister reveals: this is the date when the hostage deal will be signed

Minister Eli Cohen from the Likud party disclosed that this is the time when the deal with the captives will be finalized. He referred to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's trip to the United States and the timing when Israel is expected to reach a deal with the captives: "Military pressure has brought Hamas to surrender."

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.07.24

October 7th Massacre, Hamas, Sinwar

Report: Sinwar sent Israel a message before October 7th

News 12 journalist, Yaron Avraham, revealed tonight that Yahya Sinwar, the Hamas leader in Gaza, delivered a message to Israel several weeks before the October 7 attack, but it was not properly interpreted.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 21.07.24

Paris Olympics, Antisemitism

Shocking: French MP calls to ban Israeli Flag at Paris Olympics

Olympic controversy erupts: French lawmaker demands Israeli flag ban, sparking diplomatic row and security concerns ahead of Paris Games.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 21.07.24

Turkey, Iran, Hamas

Turkey as Iran's puppet: FM Katz slams Erdogan for allowing Hamas to plan terror attacks on Turkish soil

Following the revelation of a student terror cell in Bir Zeit funded by Hamas from Turkey, Foreign Minister Katz slammed the country for allowing it to happen on their soil.

Avi Woolf | 21.07.24

IDF, Israel-Hamas war, Gaza operation, terrorist elimination

IDF fighters eliminate a terrorist squad in Rafah, Fighting in Gaza continues

Givati Brigade's combat team identified terrorist installations in Rafah, including sites with PGMs ready for launch. The IDF's operations in the Gaza Strip persist across ground, air, and sea.

Eliana Fleming | 21.07.24

Israel-Gaza War

20 Hamas terrorists killed last Thursday include accomplice to lethal attack in 2003

The IDF eliminated Nemer Hamida last Thursday, who took part in planning a terrorist attack killing three IDF soldiers in 2003.

Avi Woolf | 21.07.24

Turkey, Terrorist Attack Foiled, ISA

Hamas attack planned by Palestinian students with Turkish connections foiled

An attack planned by students from Bir Zeit University and directed from Hamas's headquarters in Turkey has been prevented by the ISA.

Avi Nachmani | 21.07.24

Israel-Gaza War, Berkeley, Antisemitism

Legal battle intensifies over antisemitism allegations at UC Berkeley

The Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law has filed a complaint against UC Berkeley, accusing the school of pervasive antisemitism– The university is now attempting to dismiss this complaint.

Gila Isaacson | 21.07.24

Sinwar, IDF, Intelligence

IDF: Hamas intel treasure trove discovered in Gaza

Report: IDF and Shin Bet exposed a Hamas intelligence treasure trove including detailed instructions on how to act on October 7 and much more.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 21.07.24

Lammy, UNRWA, Hamas

Lammy: UK to resume UNRWA funding immediately

UK Secretary cites humanitarian necessity, while critics question oversight and agency's neutrality.

Gila Isaacson | 21.07.24

IDF, Ultra Orthodox, Mandatory Military Service

IDF has issued 1,000 call-up orders to Ultra- Orthodox men 

IDF issues first wave of draft notices to Ultra-Orthodox men, amid pushback from religious leaders and cautious approach by military officials.

Gila Isaacson | 21.07.24