Does the IDF truly want the Haredim?

How they broke Religious Zionism | Opinion

*Originally written by Udi ben Hamo and published by 'Paving the Way'. We have republished here with permission.*

Ultra-Orthodox demonstrators protest (Photo: Chaim Goldberg / Flash90)

They gathered once again in their usual meeting spot - a gleaming high-rise in central Israel. Unlike the many who merely claim to understand strategy, these people were the real deal. The words "Fortune Favors the Bold" dominated the whiteboard, a fitting motto for a group that always thought several moves ahead.

The younger members of the team often struggled to keep pace with Ehud's analytical mind (not his real name, of course).

"We need to keep pushing the ultra-Orthodox draft issue," Ehud said, settling back in his chair with satisfaction. "It's working perfectly."

"But Ehud," interrupted Danny, a former pilot now with 'Pilots for Democratic Israel,' "what if they actually enlist? The last thing we need is the military suddenly accommodating their requirements."

Ehud waved away the concern. "Everything's under control. It won't happen. The top brass are terrified of negative coverage in Haaretz or legal challenges from our NGOs about how it might affect women's service."

"It's remarkable how much influence we have in these institutions," mused Yoni, a tech sector activist who split his time between the Kaplan protests and 'Damage Coalition.' "Whoever conceived this strategy after the '77 political shift was brilliant."

Ehud leaned back with a knowing smirk. The room fell silent, sensing something bigger was coming.

"You're missing the bigger picture," he began. "What's happening here goes far deeper than you realize. But this doesn't leave the room." Right on cue, his assistant entered with non-disclosure agreements for everyone to sign.

The group admired his impeccable timing - a skill honed during his special forces days. His reputation preceded him: a master strategist who could raise endless resources, with the creativity of a genius and the daring of a young warrior.

Clearing his throat, Ehud continued: "The ultra-Orthodox draft campaign? That's just misdirection. A smokescreen for something much bigger."

"The government's collapse?" someone ventured.

"Even that's small-scale compared to our real objective. This started back with Oslo, pushing for a fundamentally different kind of state. As someone from the kibbutz movement, from the old guard that built this country, I can tell you - we're orchestrating something massive."

"Our real target is Religious Zionism's morale. In the kibbutz movement, where most of us came from, the breaking point came when people started asking, 'Why are we the only ones sacrificing everything?' Once that doubt crept in, once we stopped being single-minded pioneers - and believe me, that's brutally hard - some of us knew that crack would eventually bring down the whole wall."

"That's what'll happen to Religious Zionism within twenty years. The pressure on them is already immense, but our real victory will come when someone finally asks: 'Why do mothers in Bnei Brak sleep peacefully while mothers in the settlements lie awake?' When we hear that, we'll know we've succeeded. It won't happen overnight, but we're patient visionaries."

The room sat stunned. While they were playing checkers, Ehud was playing chess, seeing patterns before they even emerged.

As he reached the door, he turned back with a cynical smile. "Know why this will work? Because no one in Religious Zionism will dare voice what we've discussed here. Their own community would silence them for being insensitive."

The room erupted in laughter as he left. But they'd overlooked one crucial detail: the Almighty has plans of His own.

Fittingly, that Shabbat's Torah reading would tell of Abraham's test of faith and how self-sacrifice became embedded in the nation's DNA. As Mordechai reminds us: "For if you remain silent at this time, relief and deliverance for the Jews will arise from another place, but you and your father's family will perish. And who knows if you were chosen as queen especially for this moment?"

*Originally written by Udi ben Hamo and published by 'Paving the Way. Republished here with permission.*


0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

LET ARI GO!

OPINION: Why I'm ashamed to be Israeli today

Chaya Mushka Rubenstein | 08.01.25

Rabbi Yoni Levi discusses the ethics of hostage deals

Opinion: What if it was your son kidnapped in Gaza?  

Eliana Fleming | 06.01.25

Israel needs to change its security strategy for Samaria

Urgent action needed in Samaria: Addressing the root causes of terrorism

Eliana Fleming | 06.01.25

Going against the flow

OPINION: Why Haredi recruits make me PROUD

Gila Isaacson | 06.01.25

RADICAL ISLAM MEETS THE WEST 

EXPOSED: How Islamic Radicals OUTSMARTED The Entire Western World 

Hillel fuld | 02.01.25

Just another stupid, blind and truly hideous clown

The Hollow Righteousness of Greta Thunberg: A Study in Moral Failure

Gila Isaacson | 02.01.25

What was he thinking?!

OPINION: Why MK Pindrus makes my blood boil 

Gila Isaacson | 02.01.25

Hear Me Out Before Commenting

Why Benjamin Netanyahu is 2024's Man of the Year - yes, really

Avi Woolf | 01.01.25

It's Not Why You Think

Why I loathe Itamar Ben Gvir and wish he would go away

Avi Woolf | 01.01.25

Happy New Year's?

Can Jews celebrate New Year's? Here's what you need to know

Gila Isaacson | 01.01.25

As Jews are slaughtered

When it comes to the Jews, the Vatican's sickening silence is nothing new 

Chaya Mushka Rubenstein | 26.12.24

Greek culture and thought is still very much alive

Greek culture is still alive and well – What you need to know this Hanukkah

Gila Isaacson | 26.12.24

May He Smite Them All

The God of Battles: My prayer for this Hanukkah

Avi Woolf | 25.12.24

A disgraceful invention

OPINION: This is the bitter truth about "Chrismukkah"

Gila Isaacson | 24.12.24

Learning to Listen

Treading on Dreams

Jacob Schimmel | 24.12.24

 Against All Odds

OPINION: The Surprising Secret Behind Israeli Happiness

Rabbi Dov Ber Cohen | 23.12.24

Finding meaning in our magic

One little Jewish girl's Hanukkah conundrum

Gila Isaacson | 23.12.24

An impossible decision

OPINION: Noam Shalit was right – but Israel should have ignored him

Gila Isaacson | 22.12.24
Get JFeed App
Download on the App Store
Get it on Google Play