Observing Selichot

Rabbi Lau: It is appropriate to observe Selichot without musical instruments

Israel's chief rabbi, Rabbi David Lau, published a letter in response to the requests sent that "it is appropriate to observe Selichot without musical instruments, but it should not be prevented"

(Photo: Olivier Fitoussi/Flash90)

Rabbi Lau doesn't dismiss musical forgiveness. In response to inquiries that reached the office of the Chief Rabbi of Israel, Rabbi Lau, in recent days regarding the integration of musical instruments during the recitation of forgiveness prayers (Selichot), the Chief Rabbi replied that "the phenomenon of combining forgiveness prayers with musical instruments is not new and it exists. Initially, one should adhere to the manner of reciting the forgiveness prayers as they were traditionally recited without musical instruments. However, since there are those who feel that musical instruments enhance their connection to prayer, it should not be prevented."

The rabbi's full letter that was published

Furthermore, the rabbi adds and refers to past opposition to the phenomenon: "The struggle that was conducted in the past against the integration of musical instruments was due to the fact that it was the way Reform Jews prayed, introducing foreign elements, and their prayer resembled that of churches with organ playing. This was prohibited due to 'You shall not follow their statutes.' The great leaders of Israel who prohibited bringing musical instruments into the synagogue on Shabbat and holidays also prohibited it even if the musician is not Jewish. They saw in this a breach in the wall of religion."

And the rabbi concludes his letter by noting that "today the matter has settled down and it does not seem that accompanying the saying of selichot with the playing of guitars or a violin has anything to do with the customs of the Gentiles. As has been the tradition for generations, the organ is prohibited even today due to the constitutions of the Gentiles. But other musical instruments can be allowed."


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Israel-Gaza War, Antisemitism

Antisemitism worst in Denmark since WWII

The Danish Jewish community reports antisemitic incidents in numbers not seen since 1945, following a trend seen both throughout Europe and the US.

Michal Yoskovich, Jfeed Staff | 22.02.24

Israel-Gaza War, Charedim

Charedi volunteer in the IDF returns from US to serve after October 7

A Charedi who voluntarily served in the IDF and then returned home to Brooklyn put on the uniform again, leaving a family and six children behind to help out after October 7.

Avi Woolf | 22.02.24


Antisemitic attack in the US: Elderly Jew beaten outside Florida synagogue

Fort Lauderdale police arrested a 42-year-old on suspicion of beating a Jewish man outside a synagogue and calling him derogatory terms. The victim has been admitted to the hospital.

Uriel Be'eri, JFeed Staff | 19.02.24

A Siddur A Week

A Siddur A Week: The siddur as national project: the Mipi Olalim siddur and its story

In the early 1930s, the Zionist movement set to create an educational siddur for its students, to learn to pray in a native tongue and based on local traditions. This is its story.

Reuven Gafni | 16.02.24

Charedim, IDF, Opinion

All must serve, but not by force / Rabbi Shlomo Aviner

Rabbi Shlomo Aviner, a major religious Zionist Rabbi, explains the importance of both universal military service, and why coercion is not the way to get there.

Rabbi Shlomo Aviner | 15.02.24

A Siddur A Week

A Siddur A Week: The Tefillat Kol Peh Siddur and Its Influence

How large letters and an insistence on fullness rather than minimalism made the Tefillat Kol Peh siddur one of the most enduring prayer books in Israel.

Reuven Gafni | 09.02.24

Jerusalem, Beit Shemesh, Charedim

Disturbances in Jerusalem and Beit Shemesh Over Decision to Autopsy Child Found With Bruises | Watch

Hundreds of extremist Charedim gathered to block major streets in Jerusalem and Beit Shemesh in protest against an attempt to autopsy a decades 13 year old found to have physical injuries on his body.

Avi Woolf | 06.02.24

Charedim, Economy

Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics: More Charedi Men Working Than Ever Before

There are now more Charedi men working then ever before, primarily due to the pressures of high interest rates and cost of living. However, their work productivity and pay remains relatively low.

Avi Woolf | 04.02.24

A Siddur A Week

Praying With the Ben Ish Chai in Jerusalem

How a small Baghdadi publishing house took the Mizrahi world of prayer by storm - and why it ultimately faded.

Reuven Gafni | 02.02.24

Antisemitism, John Cusack

Actor John Cusack Named "Antisemite of the Week"

The organization StopAntisemitism declared John Cusack "antisemite of the week" for denying the rapes during October 7, claiming Hamas is just a "pawn" and originally a "charity organization," and more.

Avi Woolf | 29.01.24

Special Prayer at the Western Wall

Chief Rabbis of Israel in a Call to the Public

The chief rabbis of Israel, Rabbi Yitzchak Yosef and Rabbi David Lau, call to participate in a prayer meeting at the Western Wall that will be held on the eve of Rosh Chodesh Shvat.

| Guy Ezra, JFeed Staff | 01.01.24

Prayers for Rain

The Ruling of the Chief Rabbi: It is not Permissible to Postpone the Prayers for Rain Due to the War

Following questions regarding the postponement of a request for rain due to concerns that rain might be detrimental to military preparedness for war, the Rabbi replied that in the request "Grant dew and rain - for a blessing," we ask that the rain be for a blessing and not for a curse and disturbance.

Yehuda Klein, JFeed Staff | 24.10.23