The Threat to the Sukkot in Bnei Brak

The nuisance that threatens the Sukkot holiday in Bnei Brak

The rat infestation, which instills fear among the city's residents, is revealing a halachic problem in fulfilling the mitzvah of the sukkah in the building courtyards. Many rabbis in the city are addressing this phenomenon and its halachic implications

(Photo: Yaacov Naomi/Flash90)

In recent months, the city of Bnei Brak has been grappling with a severe rat infestation due to general neglect in the building courtyards and a declining hygiene situation in the city. However, now the infestation is revealing itself as a halachic issue that complicates the observance of the mitzvah of the sukkah during the upcoming holiday.

According to Jewish law, a person who is distressed is exempt from sitting and sleeping in the sukkah. However, one who is more distressed from rodents, such as many mice surrounding him incessantly, is exempt from sleeping in a sukkah in a courtyard.

Indeed, in a halachic ruling given by Rabbi Yitzchak Zilberstein, he wrote that "if he is afraid of mice, he is distressed, and he does not fulfill the obligation. However, if he is not afraid and is not repulsed or concerned, he fulfills the obligation."

Rabbi Yitzhak Zilberstein (Photo: Shlomi Cohen/Flash90)

Other judges also addressed the issue that troubles the tranquility of the city's residents. They ruled that if someone is distressed due to rodents while eating in a sukkah, they do not fulfill their obligation to observe the mitzvah in such a sukkah. However, if the distress only occurs at night while sleeping, there is room for leniency, especially when there is no possibility of building a sukkah elsewhere. Nevertheless, even in such cases, they will be careful to eat in a different sukkah on the first night, where there is no distress from rodents at all.

In a lecture that Rabbi Mazuz delivered in preparation for the holiday, he stated, "In Bnei Brak, there is a unique issue, the 'mouse plague.' This year, especially, the mice are abundant. It is impossible to stay in a sukkah with the mice; they will eat a person. If someone sleeps in the sukkah, the mice will come, and they will nibble on him from here and there... What kind of life is this? Is this a sukkah? It is impossible to sleep like this."

Rabbi Meir Mazuz (Photo: Yaacov Naomi/Flash90)

However, in practice, Rabbi's legal ruling is slightly different. He indeed stated, "In Bnei Brak, it's a national 'mouse plague.' Therefore, if a person has a sukkah downstairs where the mice come in, he is exempt from sleeping in it, but he must say kiddush and eat in it. Simply put, that's it."

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

October 7, Three Weeks

New poem connects October 7 with destruction of Jerusalem

Poet Tehila Siani has published a short poem explaining how the experience of October 7 makes the mourning of Jerusalem's destruction far more visceral for Israelis.

Avi Woolf | 23.07.24

Nazi, Holocaust, Rescue

How a British soccer player saved a Jewish teen from Nazi Germany

In Nazi Germany, a Jewish teen's desperate plea to an English soccer star sparked an unlikely rescue, as Bert Sproston's compassion on the pitch became Rolf Friedland's ticket to survival.

Gila Isaacson | 23.07.24

Michal Rapaport, Comedy, Israel Advocacy

Hilarious stand-up comedian Michael Rapaport to debut in Israel 

Actor and comedian Michael Rapaport is set to perform in Israel for the first time! His upcoming shows in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv underscore his dual role as both entertainer and outspoken supporter during this turbulent time.

Gila Isaacson | 23.07.24

October 7, Antisemitism, Europe

Survey: 80% of European Jewish leaders feel less safe than before October 7

A recent JDC survey reveals nearly 80% of European Jewish leaders feel less secure since October 7, identifying antisemitism as the foremost threat. Despite heightened fears, the survey also shows a strengthened sense of community and solidarity with Israel.

Gila Isaacson | 23.07.24

Marvel, Captain America, Sabra

Marvel U-Turn: Sabra reclaims Israeli identity after global outcry

From Mossad agent to ex-Russian spy, and back to Jewish superhero: How a shape-shifting Israeli superhero ignited debate on identity and representation in the blockbuster era.

Gila Isaacson | 23.07.24

IDF, Jewish fast, Observing soldiers, wartime

Due to wartime: Soldiers authorized to train on Jewish fast days

Ahead of the upcoming fast days and amidst the ongoing conflict, the IDF Rabbinate released a handbook containing special guidelines for soldiers deployed in the field.

Eliana Fleming | 22.07.24

Israel-Gaza War, Antisemitism

"Here I am": Shai Davidai launches new podcast on antisemitism

The Columbia University professor, famous for confronting antisemitism on campus, is now taking his efforts to the world of podcasting.

Avi Woolf | 22.07.24

U.S. Colleges, Pro-Palestinian Protests

Over 3,100 arrested during Pro-Palestine protests on college campuses– most charges were dropped  

Pro-Palestinian protests on U.S. college campuses led to over 3,100 arrests this spring– many criminal charges have been dropped, but universities continue to pursue disciplinary actions against students, including withholding diplomas and imposing campus bans.

Gila Isaacson | 22.07.24

Israel-Gaza War, Berkeley, Antisemitism

Legal battle intensifies over antisemitism allegations at UC Berkeley

The Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law has filed a complaint against UC Berkeley, accusing the school of pervasive antisemitism– The university is now attempting to dismiss this complaint.

Gila Isaacson | 21.07.24

Israel-Gaza War, Antisemitism, Protests

Chaos at SOAS: Anti-Israel encampment faces shutdown after allegations of drug possession and assault 

SOAS officials described the situation as "unmanageable," revealing that the camp had attracted individuals with no university affiliation, including "homeless people and persons wanted by the police." 

Gila Isaacson | 21.07.24

Washington Post, Hostage Families, Omer Neutra

Washington Post slammed for 'insensitive' tweet about Israeli hostage's parents - Full controversy explained

Newspaper accused of extreme insensitivity towards family of Omer Neutra, an IDF soldier still held captive by Hamas.

Gila Isaacson | 20.07.24

Columbia, Antisemitism, Funding

Billionaire Mort Zuckerman pulls $200 million donation from Columbia University

Mega-donor Mort Zuckerman pulls the plug on millions in funding, resulting from dissatisfaction in how Columbia has handled virulent antisemitism on its campus.

Gila Isaacson | 18.07.24