Discussion Today in the High Court - the Incapacity Law

Will they reject a basic law? The High Court will discuss The Incapacity Law today

At the height of the storm surrounding the Israeli legal system, the judges of the High Court of Justice will hear a petition filed against the Incapacity Law. The judges will decide whether to invalidate the amendment to the basic law, which was enacted by elected officials

High Court judges, archive (Photo: Yonatan Sindel/Flash 90)

Today (Thursday) at 10:30, the judges of the Supreme Court will deliberate on an appeal against the Incapacity Law. The dramatic hearing will be attended by President of the Supreme Court Esther Hayut, Judge Uzi Fogelman, and Judge Yitzhak Amit.

The appeal was submitted by the Movement for Quality Government and Knesset member Oded Forer from Israel Beiteinu. The petitioners argue that the amendment to "The Basic Law - the Government" drastically changes the procedure for the indictment of the Prime Minister, essentially becoming a personal law for Netanyahu following his trial and misuse of the Knesset mechanism.

The surprising battle between the legal advisors

It is worth mentioning that the Attorney General for the government, Gali Baharav-Miara, sided with the petitioners and the opinion she published argues that the law should be canceled. Miara claimed: "This is an abuse of the Knesset's authority in order to improve the personal legal situation of the Prime Minister and allow him to act contrary to the court's ruling."

Sagit Afik and Gali Baharav-Miara (Photos: Yonatan Sindel, Miriam Alster/Flash 90)

Surprisingly, the Knesset's legal advisor, Sagit Afik, vehemently opposed this opinion, claiming that the annulment of the Basic Law is an exceptional event. As a result, she requested that after today's hearing, another opinion be sent for review, representing the legal consultation of the Knesset.

Dramatic legal event: disqualification of two fundamental laws in less than two months?

It should be noted that a discussion in the Supreme Court regarding the annulment of a Basic Law is not a common occurrence, and today's hearing is considered particularly dramatic, given the legal legislation and the arguments that the power of the Supreme Court should be limited.

Esther Hayut (Photo: Yonatan Sindel, Flash 90)

In addition to today's hearing, in about a month and a half the judges of the High Court of Justice will discuss the invalidation of the law to reduce the Clause of Reasonability that was passed as an amendment to the basic law - "The Judiciary". So it turns out that in the near future and in a rather historic way, the High Court will discuss the invalidation of two basic laws ("The Government" and "The Judiciary") enacted by elected officials in the Knesset Plenum.


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

"An Unfounded Attempt"

Supreme Court on the Claim of Changing the Opening Fire Instructions: an Unfounded Attempt

High Court Following various claims that arose according to which the Supreme Court held a discussion on changing the instructions regarding opening fire after various incidents of shooting near the border fence, the Supreme Court makes it clear that these are baseless claims.

JFeed | 19.11.23

Without Authority

Levin is right: the Supreme Court acted without authority

The High Court of Justice issued a conditional order to the Minister of Justice without hearing his arguments as required by law, the court relied on the preliminary response in the petition and treated it as a full response, which is not allowed by law

Yehudit Lazarovitch, JFeed Staff | 14.09.23

Yes Atid Answers the Likud

Yes Atid answers the Likud: "The people are the sovereign, not the government"

After the Likud issued a statement against the Supreme Court judges, Yesh Atid retorted: "The people are the authority, not the government." The opposition party added and emphasized: "Another proof that the ruling party has lost its commitment to democratic values"

JFeed | 12.09.23

The Legal Reform

In the face of interference from the judges Rothman: "The people are the sovereign"

In the face of interference from the judges, the Chairman of the Constitution Committee, Simcha Rothman, demanded to reject the petitions against the Basic Law, "Don't try to take away the people of Israel's democracy and their trust in democracy."

Bentzi Rubin, JFeed Staff | 12.09.23

Distel Against the Judges of the High Court

A minister from the Likud against the judges of the High Court: 'Nobody chose them'

Minister Galit Distel criticized the judges of the Supreme Court following the hearing of the petition against the Incapacity law and claimed: "No one gave them the authority to do this"

Bentzi Rubin, Srugim News | 03.08.23

The Intervention of the High Court of Justice

"Absurd": Ayelet Shaked against the intervention of the High Court of Justice

Ayelet Shaked criticizes the Supreme Court's decision to deliberate on Basic-Law: The Government. According to her, "The Supreme Court lacks any authority to intervene in basic laws. In the past, even to the legal advice to the government this was considered obvious"

Bentzi Rubin, Srugim News | 26.07.23