The High Court Hearing Ended

After 8 hours: the High Court hearing on the Incapacity Law ended

The debate in the Supreme Court on the Incapacity Law ended after about 8 hours, and now the parties are waiting for the verdict. During the discussion, the representative of the Attorney General initially argued that she does not have the authority to disqualify the prime minister, but later changed his position

The discussion on the Incapacity Law (Photo: Haim Goldberg/Flash 90)

The discussion in the Supreme Court regarding the Incapacity law concluded this evening (Thursday) after approximately 8 hours. The parties will now await the judges' decision on the matter, and the verdict is expected to be announced in the coming months.

During the discussion, the parties addressed, among other things, the question of whether the government's legal advisor has the authority to declare Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu in incapacitation. At first, the representative of the Attorney General's Office, Aner Helman, stated that it was not within her jurisdiction. However, later on, he reversed his statement and said that the possibility of declaring Netanyahu incapacitated does fall under the authority of the legal counsel.

Initially, the President of the Supreme Court, Esther Hayut, asked Helman, "Does the Attorney General's Office see eye to eye with the Prime Minister regarding the fact that due to a conflict of interests, the Prime Minister is not disqualified from serving as a minister?" In response, Helman stated that she does not believe that the breach of the conflict of interest leads to incapacitation. Furthermore, he added that "since forever, the government's legal advisor has never had the authority to declare the Prime Minister incapacitated. According to the law, it is the government that determines whether the Prime Minister is incapacitated, not the Attorney General's Office."

Legal Advisor to the Government Gali Baharav-Miara (Photo: Natan Weil, Government Press Office)

However, after a break in the discussion, Helman changed his stance and argued that "it is impossible to rule out all possibilities in advance, so it should not seem to be that I said that a conflict of interest cannot lead to the Prime Minister's incapacitation. Let no one ever say that it is impossible due to conflicting interests to declare the Prime Minister incapacitated." After a pause in the discussion, Helman clarified himself and said, "A conflict of interest can lead to the Prime Minister's incapacitation, but only in extreme cases."

The government's lawyer: The law is no different from the laws of the previous government

Even earlier, the Chairman of the Coalition and the initiator of the amendment to the Incapacitation Law, Member of Knesset Ofir Katz, addressed the judges' allegations that there seems to be room for interpretation regarding the law's applicability, whether it will come into effect now or in the next Knesset. According to him: "As the initiator of the bill and as the chairman of the committee that managed the legislative process, I and my committee colleagues had no doubt that we were legislating a law that takes effect immediately. There is no room for an interpretation that contradicts our explicit position."

Lawyer Michael Rabilo (Photo: Haim Goldberg/Flash 90)

During the debate, Attorney Michael Rabilo, who independently represents the government's position, challenged the panel of judges: "There was a vote on Lapid's reservation, which demanded the law be applied only from the next government. It was rejected 62-44, and you did not vote in a fourth reading in the Knesset."

He also said: "The personalism you are claiming is no less serious than the personalism in the legislation of the replacement government (Netanyahu-Gantz government). They determined then that a prime minister cannot fire certain ministers, the High Court approved the law."


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Crime, Jerusalem

Criminal who terrorized Jerusalem Ultra-Orthodox neighbourhood indicted

In the heart of Jerusalem's Shmuel HaNavi neighbourhood, a young man has been arrested and charged for threatening passers-by's, stealing a bicycle, and attempting to stab a police officer with a knife, ultimately leading to him being shot and subdued.

Eliana Fleming | 21.07.24

Crime, Child Murder, Herzliya

Horrific: Mother who murdered her 6 Year-old son was 'aware of her actions' reports find 

The mother has confessed to hacking her son to death with an axe, leading police to believe the murder in Herzliya was planned and that she was aware of her actions. 

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 19.07.24

Israel Police, Terrorism

Israel Police raids villages in Judea and Samaria, seizing arms and arresting suspects

The Israel Police, together with the border guard, raided a number of villages in Judea and Samaria and seized weapons and ammunition.

Avi Woolf | 17.07.24

Crime, murder

Man found dead in central Israel in suspected murder

Suspected murder: a man's body was found in a house in the Arab town of Qalansawe, central Israel.

Eliana Fleming | 17.07.24

Crime, child murder, Herzliya

This is the mother who murdered her child in Herzliya yesterday

The name of the mother who is suspected of her 6 year-old son's murder in their apartment in a horrific violent incident was allowed to be published.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 17.07.24

Crime, child murder, violence, Israel

6 Year-old boy found dead in Herzliya in suspected child murder

Tragedy: A mother was arrested on suspicion of killing her 6-year-old son after police found his body in the Herzliya apartment.

Eliana Fleming | 16.07.24

IDF, draft law, conscription, Haredim

Next week: the IDF's dramatic step regarding the recruitment of ultra-Orthodox

A month after the High Court ruling obliging the state to recruit yeshiva students - next week the IDF will begin distributing initial recruitment orders to thousands of ultra-Orthodox.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 16.07.24

Crime, Tel Aviv shooting

Man seriously injured from shooting in Tel Aviv 

Rescue forces called to the scene of the shooting evacuated a young man, approximately 20 years old, to Wolfson Hospital during resuscitation efforts, as he was in critical condition. Police have launched an investigation and arrived at the scene to collect evidence. The background is criminal.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 15.07.24

Head of Council, sexual offences, crime

A former head of the council was arrested on suspicion of committing sexual offenses

A former council head was arrested on suspicion of harming women. The National Fraud Investigation Unit (Lahav 433) has launched an investigation against a former council head on suspicion of committing sexual offenses and harming a council employee.

Eliana Fleming | 14.07.24

Child abuse, crime, Kindergarten

Kindergarten workers charged with child abuse in Holon

Today (Wednesday), the District Court in Tel Aviv convicted Malka Malol, Eliza Cohen Tzemach, and Nur Shiloh of committing crimes of assault against minors or helpless individuals, causing actual bodily harm, among others.

Eliana Fleming | 10.07.24

Domestic Violence, Abuse, Prosecutor, Violence

Israel Prosecutor: No murder charge for man who injected his wife with cleaning materials, paralyzing her

Charges filed against Eliyahu Perez for severe abuse, leaving wife permanently paralyzed.

Gila Isaacson | 10.07.24

Crime, Shooting, MDA

Suspected Fatal Shooting in Haifa: Man killed, another injured in criminal incident

Police launch investigation into fatal incident.

Gila Isaacson | 09.07.24