Gur, IDF, Israel Police

Head of Gur Yeshiva denies draft exemption deal for Gur Hasidim, "It never happened."

Rabbi Avraham Binyamin Zilberberg strongly refutes claims of a secret agreement with the military to exempt Gur Hasidim from the draft in exchange for limited police enlistment, calling the reports "fabricated."

Shul of the Gerrer Chasidim in Jerusalem (Picture: Shuki Lerrer)

In a letter sent by Rabbi Avraham Binyamin Zilberberg to Minister Yitzhak Goldknopf, he denies the report from Galatz (IDF Radio) claiming that Gur reached an agreement with the army. He asserts that "these events never occurred."

Rabbi Zilberberg, head of the Gur Yeshiva in Hatzor HaGlilit, whose name was mentioned as having allegedly reached an agreement with the army, allowing Gur Hasidim to evade military draft orders in exchange for the enlistment of a few hundred Hasidim into the police through the army, firmly denies the report. He claims that "there is no truth to this at all."

In the letter, which he sent earlier today (Thursday) to Minister Yitzhak Goldknopf, a representative of Gur in the Agudat Yisrael faction of the United Torah Judaism party, Zilberberg completely denies the matter, saying that "someone fabricated this story."

In his letter, Rabbi Zilberberg wrote:

"I was shocked to hear about reports suggesting that I engaged in negotiations on behalf of the Gur Hasidim concerning the enlistment of some into the police in exchange for exemption from the army. This is complete nonsense.

There is no connection between this report and reality. Someone invented these claims for an unknown purpose. There have been no negotiations on this matter, and there is certainly no agreement regarding police enlistment or any such deals. It never happened.

The only issue on the agenda is to restore the previous arrangement, whereby anyone who dedicates their life to Torah study is exempt from enlistment, without conditions and without deals.

Those appointed by the great rabbis are working tirelessly to cancel this harsh decree and to return to the previous arrangement.

May you and all those engaged in this holy work be strengthened, and may the mouths of the liars be silenced."

Earlier today, Galatz reporter Yoeli Barem revealed that the Gur Hasidim had allegedly reached a deal with the Ministry of Defense, whereby they would send about 250 Hasidim to serve in various police roles, in exchange for an exemption from military service for the rest.

According to the report, Gur conducted prolonged negotiations with the Ministry of Defense, with Rabbi Avraham Binyamin Zilberberg, a key figure in Gur, leading the final discussions.

Last week, the sides reportedly reached an understanding that the majority of the Hasidim, aged 18-26 and eligible for the draft, would be exempt, while those who are already out of the study framework would enlist in police roles (even in office positions). In return, the rest of the Hasidim — the married students and the young men — would receive draft exemptions.

It is unclear what impact the exposure of this preliminary agreement by Galatz will have, as it is seen as unequal both within the ultra-Orthodox community and the general public, who have been demanding since the start of the conflict that the ultra-Orthodox community bear its share of the burden.

Galatz sought responses from the IDF, Ministry of Defense, and the police, but none were provided.

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Respected Rabbi, Moshe Hillel Hirsch, Haredi draft

Surprising: Respected Rabbi shows support for drafting of Non-Student Haredim

Eliana Fleming | 10.10.24

IAF, Nur Shams, War on terrorism, IDF Operations

IAF Aircraft attacks a terrorist cell in Nur Al Shams

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 10.10.24

Drones fired at Israel, War on terrorism, UAV threat

2 Drones aimed towards Israel shot down by IDF

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 10.10.24

Gaza war, fallen soldiers, Hamas, IDF

Heart-breaking - 2 reservists killed in Gaza have been named

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 10.10.24

Israel-Hezbollah War

Here's who the IDF was targeting in Beirut

Avi Woolf | 10.10.24

Hostages in Gaza, Bibas family, Captives alive

Major hostage update: "We received indications that Jordan Bibas is alive."

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 10.10.24

Israel-Hezbollah War

Report: Hezbollah commanders running away

Avi Woolf | 10.10.24

Israel attack on Iran, Retaliatory strikes

Iran be warned - this is what Israel has planned for you

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 10.10.24

Israel-Gaza War

IDF eliminates more October 7 murderers

Avi Woolf | 10.10.24

Israel-Hezbollah Conflict

How the IDF fought Hezbollah before its ground invasion | WATCH 

Gila Isaacson | 10.10.24
JFeed App Icon
Get the app JFeed