Skip to main content
Get our mobile app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Draft Law Coalition Talks

Change Bloc Figure Admits Draft Concession

As talks with United Torah Judaism advance on a law to settle yeshiva students' status, a senior change bloc figure says replacing Netanyahu now comes first.

A meeting of change bloc leaders

A senior figure in Israel's change bloc, the alliance of parties seeking to replace Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, has privately admitted that advanced talks with United Torah Judaism mean giving up one of the bloc's founding principles: the drafting of chareidi men into the army.

"There is no doubt that we are lowering one of our central banners, the chareidi draft," the senior figure said in a closed conversation. "It's impossible to ignore that, and if we reach an agreement we will have to explain it to the public."

The official was nonetheless clear about the bloc's priorities. "But in our considerations, every hour that Netanyahu is in the Prime Minister's Office is more dangerous than anything else, and that is our goal right now," the official said. The remarks reflect the tension within the bloc between its ideological commitments and its political aim of removing Netanyahu from office.

The admission comes as talks between change bloc representatives and United Torah Judaism (UTJ) advance. Senior UTJ figures say the two sides speak daily and have reached initial understandings on legislation that would halt the arrests of yeshiva students. A senior official in Agudat Yisrael, one of UTJ's two factions, who is involved in talks with Yisrael Beytenu leader Avigdor Liberman, confirmed that "there are initial understandings on the arrests law before a government is formed, but the main thing is the law that will regulate the status of yeshiva students."

UTJ has set two core conditions for joining a future coalition. The first is an end to the arrests before the government is sworn in. The second is a signed commitment to pass an agreed draft law before the state budget is approved.

The first demand addresses the immediate legal situation facing Torah students. UTJ wants the Knesset to pass a law stopping the arrest of yeshiva students before a new government takes office.

United Torah Judaism celebrations in Bnei Brak
United Torah Judaism celebrations in Bnei Brak (Photo: Hillel Ben Or/Flash90)

The party and the bloc want the legislation to withstand review by the High Court of Justice. According to the report, the court struck down the "Deri law" on the eve of the election, and the two sides hope to avoid the same outcome. They are therefore drafting a broader legal framework. The proposed law would not apply only to yeshiva students. It would apply equally to all deserters, chareidi and secular alike. It would also be defined as a temporary provision covering a transition period until a full draft law is passed and the status of yeshiva students is settled.

The second demand concerns the long-term status of yeshiva students. UTJ leaders accept that, for technical and legal reasons, a full and complex draft law cannot be completed before a government is formed. They are therefore demanding that every party leader in the change bloc sign the text of the agreed draft law before the government is sworn in. They also want the law passed by the Knesset before the state budget is approved.

Shas leader Aryeh Deri, meanwhile, has warned in closed conversations against chareidi lawmakers enabling a change bloc government. He argues that political promises from figures in the bloc are not backed by real guarantees. "United Torah Judaism has no guarantees that the draft law will be passed," Deri said, pointing to the parliamentary and legal timetable as the main obstacle. "The Knesset's legal adviser has already stated that the draft law cannot be passed before a government is sworn in, so if they allow a government to be formed, there is no guarantee whatsoever that they will pass the draft law."

Deri also described the balance of power that he says would follow the swearing-in of such a government, leaving the chareidi parties with no parliamentary leverage. "There will be no way to bring down a government that has a majority with the Arabs, and they won't need the chareidim for the budget either," he told the people he spoke with. He called the idea of lending votes to a change bloc government "a dangerous step" and warned of the eventual consequences for the Torah world.

Aryeh Deri arrives at the home of Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef, the Rishon LeZion, on Friday evening
Aryeh Deri arrives at the home of Rabbi Yitzhak Yosef, the Rishon LeZion, on Friday evening (Photo: Haim Goldberg/Flash90)

The office of UTJ chairman MK Yaakov Asher has firmly denied that the talks have progressed. Senior party figures, however, maintain that the negotiations with change bloc leaders have moved forward significantly. "The contacts are taking place below the surface, on a daily basis, and there is significant progress in the talks, much more than it looks from the outside," one senior UTJ figure said.

Ready for more?

Join our newsletter to receive updates on new articles and exclusive content.

We respect your privacy and will never share your information.

Enjoyed this article?

Yes
No
Follow Us:

Unmissable content


Loading comments...

Also of Interest