What is really behind the persecution of the Zionist ultra-Orthodox rabbis?

The liberal public has created in its imagination a terrifying creature with which it fights and has placed it within a convenient definition called 'Hardalim,' (Zionist ultra-Orthodox) which allows for non-substantive confrontation, while demonizing and generalizing

(Photo: No Credit)

Every person with integrity and a sensitive heart will rise up and be deeply disturbed by how, time and time again, a foolish attempt is made to pursue and discredit the President of Yeshivat Har Hamor, Rabbi Zvi Thau, Shlita, as was done in the letter of Rabbi Yaakov Medan, may he live and be well. There is no doubt that an error has occurred under his hand, and in the manner of Torah scholars, there is no doubt that he will personally fulfill the principle of "admitting and abandoning," especially in these days when anyone with a conscience will be shaken by the fear of judgment.

To the sorrow of the heart, once again, empty complaints are heard, a cycle of meaningless and boring words. I have written about this in the past, and I have no interest in reiterating the same things.

In the following lines, I will request an examination of what lies at the core of the storm, or more accurately, the attempt to breathe life into an imagined and unnecessary plot that even worthy Torah scholars are drawn into. What is the internal narrative that drives it, as it appears below? In my view, this is the tip of the iceberg of a broader struggle.

Rabbi Mordechai Sternberg refers to Rabbi Thau's case

If we haven't recognized it until now, then we must open our eyes and acknowledge that a cultural battle within the religious community is raging upon us. In general terms, we can define it as a clash between two spiritual and cultural factions within the religious public. On one hand, those who feel a commitment and loyalty to the Torah in all its aspects and are subject to the religious and spiritual authority of many of their great scholars; they view Western culture with great suspicion and remain vigilant against falling into its net, expressing skepticism regarding what society has defined as "progress and enlightenment."

On the other hand, there are liberal streams that move along a diverse spectrum, with most of them leading their lives comfortably within the common culture of Israeli society, despite its declared secularism. They even view this as a cultural achievement for advanced religious enlightenment, a realization of the vision of "the encompassing" that connects the religious and secular, a direct continuation of the Mizrahi movement but with less commitment to traditional Jewish law, and their rabbinate's opinion is seen as merely a form of a second opinion.

Over a century ago, Rabbi Kook already saw the religious seeds of the Mizrahi movement and its flexibility confronting secular Zionism. In the correspondence between Rabbi Kook and the leaders of the Mizrahi movement, we see how the rabbi, was anxious with the sight of religious people trying to please everyone and live in an indecisive duality. The latter felt a constant threat from his growing influence in recent years within the flourishing Torah world, especially among the defined Ultra-Orthodox rabbis. They perceive this as a threat to enlightenment, and it may even present a mirror that narrows the value system by which they live.

Rabbi Thau stands on the other side of the spiritual atomic reactor that is expanding and taking root within the religious community, posing a threat to religious freedom and neutralizing the infiltration of liberal values into religious fundamentalism. I understand that even within the liberal public, there are many points of light and good intentions, along with their concern for Israel's well-being according to their approach. However, their fear is no less than that of their counterparts, as there is a growing antagonism and existential persecution within them, a resurgence of the hatred of Joseph's brothers, "And they hated him, and they could not speak peacefully to him," and then, "And they conspired against him to kill him."

Before we make the effort and attempt to create dialogues with communities whose culture is currently distant from ours, it is our duty to promote inner peace, and only then will we be worthy of expanding it outward.

It is possible that the letter's author, who is known to have very close relationships, even with figures on the radical left, has for many years been engaged in an attempt to formulate a statement "in order to promote Jewish solidarity and a sense of unity and shared destiny among the different components of the Jewish people in general, and in the State of Israel in particular, and to honor each of its sectors," as stated in its opening words. However, in relation to one of the prominent rabbis, the sense of solidarity and the strong sense of protection that remains as long as no other decision has been made by a court, compel us to judge favorably and not accept slander, which is a biblical prohibition, especially when it concerns a Torah scholar and a great authority? Is it possible that brotherhood has been particularly elusive in the case of Rabbi Thau?

About twenty years ago, there was a debate regarding the study of the Bible in an institution led by Rabbi Medan himself. Even he himself, at times, promoted an interpretive approach that aims to explain the scriptures in their simplicity, sometimes even in contrast to the interpretations of the sages (Chazal), and used scientific methods. They did not hesitate to criticize the patriarchs as if they were the last sinners, a practice that was called "Bible at eye level" in his time. On the other hand, Rabbi Zvi Thau stood up and warned about the destructive influence that could arise from these study methods, especially in diminishing the great figures of the nation.

The Rabbi expressed concern that by scrutinizing their actions and comparing them to ourselves, we are essentially depriving ourselves of the ability to set a high moral standard. In doing so, we legitimize our human weaknesses since we realistically cannot live lives of pure righteousness and truth. By tarnishing their inspiration and the purity of spirit of our great leaders, we diminish our own moral expectations, adopting a mindset that "there is no righteous man on Earth who does good and does not sin" and that "all men are equal." In this way, we provide legitimacy to the teachings of the father of psychoanalysis, and the theory of impulse replaces the Torah of Israel, replacing our ability and aspiration to be "holy."

The creation of a biblical approach has facilitated the complacency that, with a wave of the hand and a lack of responsibility, allows the casting of aspersions on Torah scholars who live lives of purity and truth. Indeed, there is a stain in their hearts in relation to the possibility of finding holy individuals within us, which, in their view, is not feasible. This is evident in the dismantling of the rabbinical hierarchy within the liberal public and its rabbis, who promote discussions around roundtables where diverse and even serious ethical and halachic issues are addressed, issues that stand at the forefront of our world. In these discussions, each individual, regardless of their level of knowledge or depth of learning, can express their opinion freely.

On one hand, this allows room and a positive feeling for the average person to express their thoughts. However, on the other hand, by dismantling the rabbinical hierarchy, one does not truly grow and flourish. In essence, this is the essence of the modern post-positive approach: there is no absolute truth, and those who claim otherwise are seen as obscurantist and dangerous to enlightenment, seeking to control the masses who have departed from reason.

By the way, I am very much in favor of honest dialogue based on mutual respect with every person in the world. However, when I stand before my rabbis, I know my place, and this intimate relationship allows me to receive and progress. The liberal public has created in its imagination a frightening creature with which it fights and has placed it within a convenient definition called 'Hardalim,' (Zionist ultra-Orthodox) which allows for non-substantive confrontation, while demonizing and generalizing. But in reality, if one takes the time to meet and get to know their fellow human beings, they may find a close and humane encounter with the public and its rabbis, driven by the rightful respect for Torah scholars. There is no doubt that it can uncover sensitivity, modesty, love, and an endless dedication to public values. Then, one may realize that the distance is not as they thought, and many of the goals are similar.

I understand that such a connection between different segments of society can benefit all of us and enable us to expand our circles to include other parts of Israeli society that are still distant from our way of life. In this day and age, we should all strive to fulfill within ourselves the verse:

"וְסָ֙רָה֙ קִנְאַ֣ת אֶפְרַ֔יִם .. אֶפְרַ֙יִם֙ לֹֽא־יְקַנֵּ֣א אֶת־יְהוּדָ֔ה וִֽיהוּדָ֖ה לֹֽא־יָצֹ֥ר אֶת־אֶפְרָֽיִם"

"Then Ephraim shall not be jealous of Judah, and Judah shall not harass Ephraim", promoting unity and harmony among all segments of society.


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Israel-Gaza War, Holocaust, Antisemitism 

Disgraceful: The Jewish Holocaust survivor who hates Jews

Dr. Mate displays ghoulish ingratitude to a land which could have saved his life.

Gila Isaacson | 10:40


For how long can we afford not to war with Hezbollah?

How Netanyahu's Gaza policies emboldened Hezbollah, leading us straight into the path of war.

Gila Isaacson | 19.06.24

Public opinion, October 7th

96% of Palestinians who didn't watch footage deny October 7th Massacre, the shocking truth revealed

A latest public opinion poll by a Palestinian polling firm reveals 96% of Palestinians who did not watch October 7 footage deny that a massacre took place on October 7th.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 15.06.24

IDF, Conscription Law, Opinion

Anger over revival of conscription law, the shameful decision of the Knesset

The continuation of the controversial draft bill in Israel serves as a slap in the face to soldiers who have been serving since October 7th.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 13.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Hamas, Hostages, Opinion

Has Bella Hadid gone crazy? 

Bella Hadid glorified Hamas for making a birthday cake for an Israeli hostage that they kidnapped and tortured.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 13.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Hostages

Why Gazan civilians don't reveal the location of Israeli hostages

If Palestinian civilians know where the hostages are, why don't they tell Israel?

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 13.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, IDF, Opinion

The Relentless Spirit: Why wounded Israeli soldiers want to return to the battlefield

Driven by duty, comradeship, and resilience, wounded IDF soldiers are eager to return to the battlefield.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 11.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Lebanon, Hezbollah

Analysis: Why Israel is putting off going to war with Lebanon

Although Israel desperately wants peace in the North, it has not yet committed to an outright war with Lebanon.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 10.06.24


When Should You Put Your Baby in Kindergarten and How Do You Choose One?

Registration for educational settings for ages birth to three is just around the corner and many parents are asking themselves when is the right time to enroll their baby. So how do you choose the right framework for a child? All the details below.

Noa Leor, PhD | 10.01.24


Sivan Rahav-Meir: How Can Events Be Celebrated These Days?

The news these days are difficult and challenging. Many people are debating how to celebrate their happy events. The Yarchi family, whose son celebrated a Bar Mitzvah, found a unique way to express the joy.

Sivan Rahav-Meir | 19.12.23

'Brothers in Arms'

'Brothers in Arms' for Real and not as a Slogan | Rabbi Shachar Botschak

These days, the same citizens who were in the demonstrations of both sides enter the same tank, the same squad of fighters, and fight for weeks when every moment they are shoulder to shoulder, and their lives depend on each other.

Rabbi Shachar Botschak | 07.12.23

Sivan Rahav-Meir

A Kitchen, a Hotel, and a Tunnel: Three Stories That Really Happened

From the hotel kitchen through Tefillin at the base to the captivity tunnels of Hamas - new chapters of kindness and generosity are being written here,  between man and his Maker and between a man and his friend.

Sivan Rahav-Meir | 29.11.23