Israel-Gaza War, Settlers, Opinion

Anti-Settler Sanctions Send the Wrong Message to Everyone

A small number of violent settlers do not justify a special sanctions regime which could be expanded to pressure Israel into agreeing to a presently existentially threatening Palestinian state.

(Photo: Miriam Alster/Flash90)

The October 7th massacre has created a rare political consensus in Israeli society.

Whether on the political right, left, or center, there is a widespread understanding that a Palestinian state poses an existential threat to the State of Israel. Contrary to Western platitudes, Hamas does indeed represent a significant majority of Palestinian society. Even the ostensibly moderate Fatah has denied, minimized, celebrated and encouraged Hamas' slaughter, with the Palestinian Authority set to pay Hamas' fighters and their families.

In such a reality, a Palestinian state would all but guarantee a repeat of October 7th in Israel's main cities, only a few kilometers away. Despite this, many in the international community has concluded that this is precisely the time to pressure Israelis into reviving the "two state solution".

On February 4th, US President Joe Biden took the unprecedented step of issuing sanctions against four Israeli citizens accused of violence against Palestinians in Judea and Samaria. In December, the US and the UK announced a travel ban on settler extremists. Canada, the UK and the EU are contemplating expanding the sanctions regime.

In his executive order, Biden stated that settler violence "undermine[s] the foreign policy objectives of the United States, including the viability of a two-state solution and ensuring Israelis and Palestinians can attain equal measures of security, prosperity, and freedom."

While sanctions are currently limited to four individuals, it is likely that Biden and other leaders will face internal pressure to expand the sanctions to Israeli right-wing politicians or even military commanders defending settlements.

Certainly, Israeli extremists that target Palestinians must be dealt with to the full extent of Israeli law.

However, sanctions against Israeli petty criminals create a false equivalence with Hamas terrorists, also the target of American and international sanctions. Hamas is a highly coordinated organization, which enjoys high-level Iranian, Qatari and Turkish patronage, and which until recently served as the de facto government of the Gaza Strip. It is responsible for the murder and maiming of thousands of Israelis, among them American citizens.

By contrast, "settler violence" is a sporadic phenomenon, carried out by opportunistic thugs, absent any coordination or organization. While reprehensible, settler lawlessness is largely confined to harassment and vandalism, carried out by a few individuals out of the total half-million Jews living beyond the Green Line.

Of course, settler violence pales in comparison to the scale of Palestinian terror. According to the Israeli Shin Bet, 2023 saw an average of 200 terrorist attacks per month, with 50 Israelis murdered (not including the October 7th attack). Whatever one's position on Israeli settlements, it is misguided to lump a few Israeli hoodlums in with the much larger problem of Palestinian terrorists.

Settler thugs justifiably do not elicit much support even from Israel's supporters. However, Israel and its allies must mobilize against the sanctions regime lest it become a tool to punish Israeli "two state" realists. Israel's leadership may find itself under intense pressure to make dangerous security concessions for fear of being locked out of American and international financial systems.

The renewed push for a Palestinian state while Palestinian society continues to glorify and perpetrate mass slaughter against Jews is misguided and a recipe for more bloodshed. In the wake of the greatest attack on Jews since the Holocaust, sanctions and international pressure must be applied to Palestinian terrorists and their enablers, not Israelis who clearly recognize the danger.

Avraham Russell Shalev is a lawyer and researcher in the Kohelet Policy Forum's legal department.

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Israel-Gaza War, Antisemitism, Protests

Chaos at SOAS: Anti-Israel encampment faces shutdown after allegations of drug possession and assault 

SOAS officials described the situation as "unmanageable," revealing that the camp had attracted individuals with no university affiliation, including "homeless people and persons wanted by the police." 

Gila Isaacson | 07:16

October 7, Intelligence, Hamas

How Israel ignored warnings of Hamas attack for at least 7 years

New reports reveal Hamas planned attack for nearly a decade as Israel's spy agencies misread threats. How did a nation renowned for its intelligence prowess miss the signs of impending disaster?

Gila Isaacson | 07:05

Netanyahu, Biden, Hamas

Netanyahu in Race Against Time on Hostage Deal

Israeli PM meets negotiators before critical US trip as pressure mounts.

Gila Isaacson | 06:54

Washington Post, Hostage Families, Omer Neutra

Washington Post slammed for 'insensitive' tweet about Israeli hostage's parents - Full controversy explained

Newspaper accused of extreme insensitivity towards family of Omer Neutra, an IDF soldier still held captive by Hamas.

Gila Isaacson | 20.07.24

IDF, Israel Airstrikes, Hezbollah commander killed

IDF Eliminates Hezbollah Radwan force senior commander

IDF takes down senior Radwan leader and 6 other Hezbollah members in Lebanon in one day. Hezbollah confirmed the strike, acknowledging Habib Maatouk's death.

Eliana Fleming | 19.07.24

Israel-Gaza War

IDF Spokesperson: Hamas hiding Deif's condition, odds of his death increasing

In response to a question regarding Deif, IDF Spokesperson Daniel Hagari noted that Deif was sitting next to Rafa'a Salameh, who was confirmed dead, when the strike happened.

Liran Vainshtain, JFeed Staff | 19.07.24

Terror attack, Injured IDF soldiers, Hermesh

Terror Attack in Hermesh: The Injured are IDF Soldiers on vacation

Two IDF soldiers on leave were lightly and moderately injured as a result of an explosion of an explosive device near the community of Hermesh. Two additional civilians were injured lightly. Hamas claimed responsibility for the attack.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 18.07.24

Hostage release, ceasefire deal, Israel-Hamas

Report: Abu Mazen is  Preventing a Deal for the Release of Hostages

The unofficial Palestinian Authority's agreement to control the Rafah crossing was supposed to pave the way for negotiations to release hostages. However, Abu Mazen has refused, and the talks are no longer progressing.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 18.07.24

Israel-Gaza War

Coalition and opposition MKs to Biden: Withdraw sanctions against Tzav Tesha protest movement

A letter signed by the MKs notes how the movement itself voluntarily froze its operations, how Hamas does end up stealing the aid, and how it opposed violence.

Avi Woolf | 18.07.24

Israel-Gaza War

IDF releases recording of Gazan civilians celebrating the death of Deif | Watch

While the death of Mohammad Deif has not yet been confirmed, conversations such as these are evidence of increasing discontent with the war and Hamas.

Avi Woolf | 18.07.24

Israel-Gaza War

PM Netanyahu visiting Rafah: Military pressure helps hostage negotiations

During a visit to the troops in the Rafah area, Netanyahu stated that holding the Philadelphi corridor and the Rafah crossing were "vital" for the war effort.

Avi Woolf | 18.07.24

IDF, Fallen soldier, Hezbollah

IDF publishes identity of soldier killed by Hezbollah missile

Allowed for publication: Slain Soldier names as Sergeant Major Ephraim Ben Amram who passed away from his injuries. He was seriously wounded after a Hezbollah drone attack late last month before succumbing to his wounds.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 18.07.24