50th Anniversary of the Yom Kippur War

50 years since the Yom Kippur War | Dayan reports to the government: "The Arab threat is much higher than we estimated"

Protocols revealed by the State Archives on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the Yom Kippur War show the intelligence failures presented to the heads of the leadership as well as the astonishment that gripped them when the war broke out during the government meeting

(Photo: Moshe Milner/Government Press Office)

50 years since the Yom Kippur War, today (Thursday), the State Archives publishes thousands of photos, documents, recordings, and records that tell the story of the difficult war, the warnings issued before its outbreak, the indifference that gripped the country's leaders, security consultations, government meetings, and other materials.

Much has been said about the lack of understanding by those in leadership regarding the ongoing and approaching war. The exposed protocols emphasize the insights and show that despite the warnings given, decision-makers delayed in preparing the territory for the war and relied on the IDF as an invincible army.

Moshe Dayan during his visit to the West Bank of the Suez Canal at the outbreak of the war (State Archives)

On October 3, 1973, three days before the war, a military and political consultation was held at the office of Prime Minister Golda Meir. In a report presented by Arie Shalev, head of research at Aman (Military Intelligence Directorate), it was stated that "Syria's intentions to open a short-term war are well known to us."

"I don't see the danger as concrete for the near future"

Chief of Staff David (Dado) Elazar dismissed the concerns and said, "At this stage, I don't think we are facing a joint Egyptian-Syrian attack. There are joint plans, they always were. A joint attack by them is, of course, possible, but it depends on the political and military situation. It could happen one day, but I don't see the danger as an immediate one."

We are not facing a joint Egyptian-Syrian attack. Dado's words (State Archives)

On the morning of the day of the war, a government meeting is held. Reports of the forced evacuation of women and children by the Russians in Russia and Egypt indicate that the Arabs are planning an attack on Israel. The conclusion of those present is that the attack will begin at nightfall, right after Yom Kippur. Moshe Dayan tells the participants, "It is clear that the headquarters wants us to initiate a preventive strike before they open fire on us, but the Defense Minister still declares: 'Until they open fire, even if we see and know that they are preparing all of this for us, we will not be the first to open fire in the war.'"

As the meeting was concluding, sirens were heard going up and down. Afterward, Lieutenant Colonel Israel Lior, the military secretary of the Prime Minister, entered and reported, "It's already starting, and there are escalations in Syria. The Syrians have opened fire."

"It's starting, the Syrians have opened fire." - Lieutenant Colonel Israel Lior (Photo by Moshe Friedman/GPO)

"We have a very difficult war, difficult battles"

At the same time, the Prime Minister was concerned about the situation in the political struggle against the Arabs and their supporters who sought to portray Israel as the aggressor in the attacks on Syria and Egypt. During the meeting held towards the end of the day, right after Yom Kippur, Golda Meir reacted strongly to the statements made by Mobutu Sese Seko, the President of Congo, who suggested that there might be no choice but to sever relations with Israel: "From Mobutu, it's truly demeaning; there's no better word for it. What haven't we done for his country and for him? If he has an army, it's all thanks to us. And just a few days ago, he requested that officers who were about to return home stay with him."

In the government meeting held the following day, on October 7th, a tense atmosphere prevailed. The Chief of Staff opened his remarks and told the cabinet members, "We are in the containment stage, and it is indeed a difficult stage. We are facing a very tough war, and the battles are hard. It has become clear that the Egyptians have achieved somewhat more, but they have exhausted themselves, and their progress has been hindered. On the other hand, the Syrians succeeded in breaking through significantly during the last hours of the night."

The battles are very difficult. Evacuation of the wounded in the combat zone (State Archives)

In another meeting held on the same day, towards evening, Defense Minister Moshe Dayan confessed, "I want to confess that my assessment before this war was much lower in terms of how the Arabs would fight and much higher in terms of our capabilities in relation to the existing forces. The results we are seeing now in the battle show that the Arab fighting is much stronger than we anticipated, and our ability to cope with the unfavorable balance of forces is not yielding the expected results."

The crossing of the canal and the cease-fire agreement were successful

Operation "Abirei Lev" was a turning point in the war in which the IDF initiated a series of battles with the aim of successfully opening the Suez Canal and occupying the territory to its west, culminating in the defeat of the third Egyptian army. From the exposed protocols, it is revealed that in a special discussion held three days before the operation, Chief of Staff Elazar expressed concerns about whether this action would collapse the Egyptian army and contribute to the desired ceasefire from his perspective.

The Chief of Staff's concerns regarding the success of the canal crossing operation (State Archives)

In a report provided by Lieutenant General Israel Tal, Deputy Chief of Staff to the Prime Minister during the middle of the battle, said that "the Egyptians have not yet figured it out, we have deceived them and their attention is diverted there. We were lucky, and our artillery held up under heavy fire. In war, it's impossible to know; this could be a decisive operation unlike any other." The successful completion of the canal crossing operation was a significant turning point in the war.

On October 24, the ceasefire came into effect.

Notice of the ceasefire (State Archives)

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Red Sea, Suez Canal, Houthis

Egypt Forced to Raise Suez Canal Rates Due to Reduced Traffic

The decline in shipping via the Red Sea and the Suez Canal due to Houthi attacks is starting to hit Egyptian toll revenues. Egypt is trying a number of ways to compensate.

Avi Woolf | 29.01.24

Israel-Gaza War, Houthis, Shipping

Egypt Faces Potentially Serious Revenue Shortfall from Houthi Red Sea Blockade

The Iran-backed Houthis have forced many shipping companies to either bypass the Red Sea or announce an end to shipping to Israel. But Egypt also suffers from the loss of revenue from ships now not using the Suez Canal.

Avi Woolf | 18.12.23

Henry Kissinger has Passed Away

US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger has Passed Away

At the age of 100, the legendary US Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, winner of the Nobel Peace Prize, has passed away. He will be remembered as the one who pressed Israel for concessions in the Yom Kippur War and received the nickname "Husband of the Gentile" from Rabbi Zvi Yehuda.

JFeed | 30.11.23

Israel At War

In the Wake of the Houthi Terrorism: ZIM in a Dramatic Message

The ZIM company sent a message to its customers, that the cargo ships and shipments would deviate from the original route in the Red Sea, due to the threats from the Houthis, which would cause a great delay in the delivery of shipments to Israel.

Yehuda Klein, JFeed Staff | 29.11.23

A Hostile Takeover

Biden's Assistance Turned Out to be a Hostile Takeover of the Situation

Joe Biden was a member of the Senate back during the Yom Kippur War. He is well-versed in the American approach: provide generous assistance to Israel when it's in distress and then exert military and diplomatic pressure according to U.S. interests.

Arye Yoeli, JFeed Staff | 16.10.23

The Bold Halachic Solution

The bold halachic solution of Rabbi Ovadia Yosef ztz"l

Fifty years after the war, the special rabbinical court established under the leadership of the Chief Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, may his memory be blessed, was revealed, along with the bold halakhic solution it found for the difficult crisis

JFeed | 04.10.23

Gallant Threatens Hamas

Gallant sends a threat to Hamas: "We will not hesitate to use force"

Minister of Defense Yoav Gallant: "This evening, it is important that we remind the terrorist elements in Gaza of the true power dynamics between the IDF and Hamas and its partners"

Simcha Raz, JFeed Staff | 27.09.23

Yom Kippur War

The engineering officer who lost both his legs: "The task was to complete the bridge"

David Cohen, who served as an engineering officer, warned in a report to the commander of the Southern Command about the war. Before the crossing, he was one of the builders of the bridge over the Suez Canal and lost both legs in shelling but stands firm in his strong faith

Yehudit Lazarovitch, JFeed Staff | 22.09.23

The Legal Reform

Gallant: "Questioning the Declaration of Independence harms the state"

Defense Minister Gallant in his speech at a rally commemorating the 50th anniversary of the Yom Kippur War of the Armored Corps: "The Declaration of Independence embodies the foundations upon which the state was built and exists"

Bentzi Rubin, JFeed Staff | 21.09.23

The Hidden Photographs are Revealed

50 years later: the hidden photographs from the Yom Kippur War are revealed

50 years after he shot footage during the Yom Kippur War, journalist Ron Ben Yishai returns to unpublished photos and combines them into a film that tells the story of the battle on the Suez Canal front. Watch

Rinat Kramer Jablinowitz, JFeed Staff | 21.09.23

"We Must be Prepared"

The Chief of Staff: We must be more prepared than ever for a military confrontation

The Chief of Staff spoke at the central IDF ceremony marking 50 years since the Yom Kippur War: "We must take every statement of our enemies seriously, whether in words or in deeds; not to underestimate them"

JFeed | 11.09.23

Documents Revealed

50th anniversary of the Yom Kippur War: Do you recognize the praying soldiers?

50 years after the Yom Kippur War, the state archives reveal to the public thousands of documents and photos, including records of soldiers praying in the Sinai desert and across the Suez Canal. Do you identify the people photographed?

JFeed | 07.09.23