Surprising
Judge Makes Surprising Decision in Charlie Kirk Murder Case
Utah judge grants Charlie Kirk murder suspect Tyler Robinson the right to wear civilian clothes during pretrial hearings, citing presumption of innocence, while keeping him handcuffed; prosecutors still seek the death penalty.
The judge presiding over the murder trial of Tyler Robinson, accused of assassinating political activist Charlie Kirk, made a surprising ruling in favor of the defendant.
Judge Tony Graff, overseeing the trial of Robinson, who is charged with killing the right-wing activist Charlie Kirk, cited the “presumption of innocence” as a central reason for his decision. The Utah County District Attorney’s Office announced it intends to seek the death penalty in the case.
Robinson, 22, was arrested on September 12, charged with murder with aggravating circumstances after Kirk was shot and killed while speaking at the University of Utah.
Yesterday, Judge Graff ruled that Robinson may wear civilian clothing during pretrial hearings to avoid biasing potential jurors. However, Robinson will remain handcuffed throughout the proceedings, and photographing or recording him while restrained is prohibited.
The judge emphasized that, although the defendant has no prior criminal record, the charges are particularly serious and courtroom security is a top priority: “The safety of Mr. Robinson, the attorneys, court staff, and the public is paramount,” Graff stated. He added that the emotionally charged nature of the proceedings increases the risk of disruptions, which justified the continued use of restraints.
Robinson did not attend the hearing in person, which was conducted virtually. His next court appearance is scheduled for January 16. He faces seven charges, including murder with aggravating circumstances, obstruction of justice, and use of a firearm in a criminal act. Utah prosecutors confirmed their intention to pursue the death penalty.