Yesh Atid Petitions Against the Legal Reform

Yesh Atid petitions against the Basic Law: "There was no proper procedure"

The "Yesh Atid" party is filed an appeal to the Supreme Court against the reduction of The Clause of Reasonability: "In the text of the law, not a single comment from the Members of Knesset was included. It seems that a deliberate intent prevented a thorough, comprehensive, and substantive work process"

(Photo: Haim Goldberg/Flash 90)

The appeal was submitted today (Wednesday) by Members of Knesset Karine Elharrar, Yoav Segalovich, and the "Yesh Atid" party against the Minister of Justice, Yariv Levin, and the Government of Israel, regarding the promotion of the law to reduce the Clause of Reasonability.

It should be noted that the Supreme Court has already scheduled a hearing on the matter, which is expected to take place on September 12 before the full panel of all 15 Supreme Court justices.

The appeal details the claim of how the discussions in the Constitution, Law, and Justice Committee, in which Members Elharrar and Segalovich participated, were treated as a "mere formality" initiated by the Minister of Justice, Yariv Levin. Among other things, it was written there: "It is not a bill proposed by a committee but a bill proposed by the Minister of Justice, who activated the Constitution, Law, and Justice Committee and MK Rotman as his long arm, all while undermining the Knesset's regulations, the principle of separation of powers, and proper procedure."

The Constitution Committee (Photo: Yonatan Zindel/Flash 90)

Furthermore, the appeal describes how a proper process was not followed in the Constitution, Law, and Justice Committee, and it was written there: "Although it boasted in the title 'Bill proposed by the committee,' it did not even come close to a process similar to the preparation of a government bill. In fact, it is clear to all that a deliberate decision was made to avoid a systematic, comprehensive, and substantive process. Whoever chose to convert the government bill into a bill disguised as 'proposed by the committee' did so in order to prevent such a process."

Elharrar: "Rotman exploited his position"

The petitioners request from the Supreme Court to grant an injunction on the law due to flaws in the legislative process, as the amendment to the Basic Law contradicts the fundamental principles of the Israeli system of government, violating the principle of separation of powers and the ability of the judiciary to perform its role and oversee the legality of the executive actions.

Furthermore, they added that the amendment to the Basic Law changes the checks and balances on which the oversight of the executing authority in Israel is built - an authority that is in itself an essential cornerstone of a democratic society. Therefore, the amendment to the Basic Law is a constitutional amendment, not a lawful one, and its validity should be nullified.

Knesset Member Karine Elharrar, who submitted the appeal, stated: "The enactment of the Basic Law to annul the Clause of Reasonability was done solely to grant the executing authority additional power beyond what it already possesses. This undermines the checks and balances, which are fundamental principles in the Israeli legal system, using the framework of the Basic Laws. The appeal was submitted because the legislative process was conducted improperly and cynically using tools available to the Chairman of the Knesset Committee. Knesset Member Rotman exploited his position and acted as an emissary of the Minister of Justice in the legislative process on behalf of the Committee, thus weakening the position of the legislative authority. This harmful manner of legislation in itself justifies the nullification of the law."

Karine Elharrar (Photo: Yonatan Sindel/Flash90)

To this, Knesset Member Yoav Segalovich added: "Throughout the legislative process, there were no in-depth discussions of the central issues, no legal advisors from government ministries were present for consultations, and there was no discussion of the international implications of annulling the Clause of Reasonability and the ability to protect IDF soldiers and security forces from international tribunals. These flaws are rooted in the legislative process, which was entirely flawed and invalid, disguised as a proposal from the committee, irrelevant, and defective, turning the Knesset into a rubber stamp for the government."

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Israel-Gaza War, Palestinian State

Cabinet set to sanction PA and states which recently recognized Palestinian state

Informed sources say the cabinet is set to vote on a number of sanctions against the Palestinian Authority and states which recently decided to recognize a State of Palestine.

JFeed Staff | 16.06.24

Israel-Gaza War

Report: IDF inquiry reveals anti-tank missile killed soldiers in Rafah APV

According to the inquiry, the rocket, which targeted an APV of combat engineers, detonated mines and explosives, dooming the passengers.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

Iran, Culture

Iran vs. Barbie: Khamenei declares toys a "cultural invasion" to be stopped

Despite efforts at clampdowns, though, toys and other western items continue to make their way into the theocratic state.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Hostages

Ynet: Senior Israeli source says Hamas response on truce "absolutely negative"

A source speaking to Ynet said that as far as Israel was concerned, either Hamas agrees to the Biden parameters as written, or there is no deal.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

Houthi attacks, Ship hijacking

US Navy saves Greek crew from Houthi attack

Ship hijackings continue by the Iran-backed Houthi terrorist group, causing destruction and terror to cargo ships in the Red Sea over the past months.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 16.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, October 7

Channel 14: IDF finds tank shell did not kill hostages in Beeri

After many months of investigations including archaeological excavations, Brig.-Gen. Barak Hiram appears to have been cleared of responsibility for allegedly accidentally killing hostages.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

IDF

IDF meets with local leaders from border regions

IDF Rear Command commander Maj.-Gen. Rafi Milo met with leaders of local communities in the border regions to discuss efforts to protect cooperate with them.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

Politics, Elections

Poll shows Gantz dropping, Liberman rising

A poll done for Maariv by Menachem Lazar shows Benny Gantz's party continuing its decline from its peak at the beginning of the war, with just 24 seats.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Politics

Gantz and Netanyahu's parties exchange barbs over who's "defeatist" in the war against Hamas

The former political allies in the war against Hamas are now engaging in bitter recrimination over the decisions made when they both served in the war cabinet.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

Protest Movements, Israel

New protest movement launched by Israel's northern citizens

After being under continuous attack with hundreds of rockets fired at them from Lebanon, northern Israeli citizens have had enough and demand security for the region and people.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 16.06.24

Israel-Gaza War

Chief of Staff Halevi: We're encouraging Haredi enlistment

Halevi spoke to soldiers of how "every battalion" formed from Haredi recruits helps relieve thousands of reservists from defensive duties.

Avi Woolf | 16.06.24

US-Israel ties, Navy

Israeli Navy confirms arrival of new landing craft

The Israeli Navy has just received its second of two landing crafts from the US. The ship docked at Haifa's naval base just hours ago.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 16.06.24