Ruling: AI Creations Not Protected

Dramatic ruling: AI creations are not protected by copyright

A judge in the United States ruled that a creation generated by artificial intelligence is not attributable to the human creator and therefore does not have copyright rights. This ruling could have implications for an entire industry of new creators specializing in artificial intelligence

Artificial intelligence creation (Photo: Ascannio/shutterstock)

Last week, Judge Beryl A. Howell of the U.S. District Court issued a dramatic ruling that shook the artificial intelligence creators community. In response to a lawsuit filed by Dr. Stephen Thaler against the U.S. Copyright Office, the judge determined that in these creations made by machines, there is no human creative element, and therefore they do not have copyright rights.

Thaler attempted several times to approach the Copyright Office in order to obtain rights for a creation he produced using artificial intelligence. However, after being rejected repeatedly, he decided to file a lawsuit against the Office in the District Court. In his lawsuit, he argued that the Office's rejection was arbitrary and contrary to the law.

As mentioned, Judge Howell who heard the lawsuit ruled that it is not possible to give copyright to the creations of artificial intelligence and to the author of the algorithm. According to her, a creation in which there was no guiding human hand is not subject to copyright, and a human creator is a fundamental requirement of copyright.

This ruling shakes up the industry where many creators and illustrators have begun to incorporate in their works the popular tools Midjourney or DALL·E, which create images by writing text, but now according to the ruling in the US their new works are not under copyright protection, which may harm their livelihood.

Thaler has already indicated that he intends to appeal the court's verdict he received, as his legal representative stated, "We disagree with the court's interpretation of copyright law." The creators' community will undoubtedly follow the continuation of the trial, the outcome of which will have far-reaching implications for an industry that is still in its infancy.


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Tech, Apple

AFP: EU hits Apple with €1.8 billion fine for not allowing streaming services to mention subscription options outside Apple

The fine came thanks to a complaint by major streaming company Spotify.

Avi Woolf | 04.03.24

October 7 Massacre, Binance

Survivors of October 7 sue Binance for allowing money transfers to Hamas and Islamic Jihad

Binance, the world's largest cryptocurrency exchange, is now being sued in US court for allowing the financing of terrorist groups on their platform.

Avi Woolf | 29.02.24

Mekorot, Hydroelectrity, Environment

Israeli Water Company Mekorot to Build New Hydroelectric Plant in the South

The turbine powering the plant is expected to produce some 3.5 million kilowatt-hours a year, or enough to power a 500-family town for a whole year.

Avi Woolf | 06.02.24

Israel-Gaza War, Antisemitism, TikTok

President Herzog Presents Senior TikTok Executives With Evidence of Antisemitism Problem on Platform

The meeting comes against the background of growing controversy over TikTok's moderation policies towards openly antisemitic content.

Avi Woolf | 06.02.24

Artificial Intelligence, Microsoft

Windows to Introduce AI Button on New Windows 11 Computers

This is the first time Windows keyboards have been updated since the Windows button was introduced in the 1990s. The key will appear to the right of the space bar.

Avi Woolf | 04.01.24

Israel, Technology, Artificial Intelligence

Israel Launches Supercomputer Ahead of Schedule

Technological giant NVIDIA has completed the first stage in constructing the Israeli supercomputer Israel-1 and has declared it operational. 

| JFeed | 21.11.23

The Target Bank

This is how the Target Bank is Built: Thousands of Soldiers and Artificial Intelligence

Intelligence forces construct a database of targets during the fighting, using artificial intelligence. The information is transmitted in real-time to the ground forces operating in the area and in collaboration with the Air Force.

Yehuda Klein, JFeed Staff | 02.11.23

Windows 11 New Update

Windows 11 changed its face with a new update

Microsoft bombards its popular operating system with many artificial intelligence-based features, the highlight of which is the 'Copilot' that will be permanently placed on the desktop as a sidebar

Yehuda Klein, JFeed Staff | 27.09.23

Netanyahu And Musk, Live

Netanyahu and Musk, Live: "This is the greatest threat to humanity"

Prime Minister Netanyahu and the entrepreneur of the companies "Tesla" and "SpaceX" Elon Musk sat down for a special conversation live on the subject of AI

JFeed | 18.09.23

A Backpack Based on AI

Microsoft is planning: a backpack based on artificial intelligence

Microsoft has applied for a patent for the design of a backpack based on artificial intelligence, according to the publication on the mspoweruser website the bag will serve as a 'digital assistant' without hand contact and physical use

Yehuda Klein, JFeed Staff | 05.09.23

ChatGPT's Business Version

Starting to earn: ChatGPT Business version has been launched

After nine months in which the popular chat functioned in the free version, OpenAi launched a business version for premium users that can adapt to the needs of different organizations

Yehuda Klein, JFeed Staff | 29.08.23

Google Adds New Features

New search: Google updates the mobile search

In order to maintain relevance and compete with new content search options on the web, Google is introducing significant changes to its mobile search engine that will enhance the search experience

Yehuda Klein, Srugim News | 06.08.23