Skip to main content
Get our mobile app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Media

Amnon Levy on 'Neza' film controversy

Veteran Israeli broadcaster reviews controversial documentary featuring IDF intelligence soldiers' testimonies, criticizes lack of proof but calls it very important

Amnon Levy on 'NAZA' film: Very Difficult to Digest, but Sparked Debate on a Silenced Issue

Israeli broadcaster Amnon Levy shared his reaction after watching "Neza," a documentary presenting testimonies from IDF intelligence soldiers about decision-making processes and civilian casualties during the Gaza war.

In a post published today, Levy described the viewing experience: "I watched Neza today. Eighty very difficult minutes to digest. The film contains no horror scenes, except at the end, and yet it is shocking. The difficulty comes from testimonies of intelligence soldiers who describe in detail how they themselves killed thousands of civilians who were collateral damage."

Levy detailed the content shown in the film, noting that the soldiers describe, in relaxed conversations on a Tel Aviv rooftop, the intelligence mechanism for deciding to bring down buildings, listening to children's phone calls to locate Hamas suspects, and how the number of uninvolved civilian casualties was priced. According to him, the soldiers describe how statements that there are no innocents in Gaza served as fuel for these processes, with everything carried out technically and without moral difficulty in real time.

At the same time, Levy sought to clarify that contrary to certain claims, the film does open with the October 7 massacre that triggered the war, though this is not its focus.

Levy also leveled journalistic criticism at the way the testimonies are presented in the film: "It must be said that all the witnesses are shadowed, there is no location, no time or date for any story. There is also no other supporting evidence. The testimonies do sound credible because they are detailed and full of technical intelligence knowledge, but this is problematic for such a difficult and challenging film that you have to believe without unequivocal proof."

Despite the reservations and criticism of the investigation, Levy summed up his impression of the work and determined that it is "a very important film that has already succeeded in sparking an intense debate on a silenced issue."

Ready for more?

Join our newsletter to receive updates on new articles and exclusive content.

We respect your privacy and will never share your information.

Enjoyed this article?

Yes
No
Follow Us:

Unmissable content


Loading comments...

Also of Interest