Response to Rabbi Zalmonovich

It is permissible to pray in the street/response to Rabbi Zalmonovich

Rabbi Efraim Zalmonovich, the rabbi of Mazkeret Batya, argued that one should not pray in public spaces and justified his words with Torah law. In my opinion, his statements are not accurate, and I would like to ask a few questions about his conclusion

(Photo: Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)

Rabbi Efraim Zalmonovich, shlita, who serves as the rabbi of Mazkeret Batya, claimed that one should not pray in public spaces, and he justified his statements based on Torah law. In my opinion, his words are not accurate, and I would like to ask several questions about his conclusion:

1. The Talmud in Megillah 26a brings up that during fasts and public gatherings, people used to pray in the streets of the city. Therefore, the Talmud considers whether the street might become sanctified for prayer.

2. Maimonides, in "Hilchot Tefillah u'Nesi'at Kappayim", Chapter 11, Halacha 21, states: "The street of a city, although the people pray in it during fasts and gatherings, because the congregation is large, and there are no synagogues that can contain them, it does not have sanctity because it is temporary and not designated solely for prayer. Similarly, houses and courtyards in which people gather for prayer do not have sanctity, because they have not designated them solely for prayer, but people pray in them temporarily, like a person praying in his home."

Is explanation provided by Maimonides not clear enough to permit public prayer outdoors when there is a large congregation? Is the Rabbi familiar with synagogues that can contain thousands of people?

3. The assertion made by the Rabbi that he prohibited praying outdoors during the COVID-19 pandemic is indeed perplexing and seemingly contradicts the views of many other rabbis worldwide. He should explain the source for his ruling, as it appears to differ from the Talmudic source that deals with praying in a valley, the Shulchan Aruch (Code of Jewish Law), and the opinions of earlier authorities. It is evident from historical sources that as long as there is a minyan (a quorum of ten Jewish adults required for certain prayers) gathered, there shouldn't be an issue with outdoor prayer. Therefore, some may question why Yitzhak prayed in an open field?

4. In the entire world, people prayed in open spaces with minyanim (prayer quorums) during the COVID-19 pandemic, and it seems appropriate to do so.

5. This is not about a protest or using religion, but about the desire to include more and more Jewish people.

6. Furthermore, the Zohar in Parashat of Beshalach (not Shalach, as mentioned in the article by Rabbi Zalmonovich) is written about the greatness of the synagogue and the importance of its construction. This serves as a rebuke against those who allowed praying in a public square during the pandemic to the extreme. It is clear that every Torah scholar knows how to distinguish and prioritize when it is possible or impossible.

7. This halacha, as is known, is not mentioned in the Rif and the Rambam.

8. It seems that Rabbi Zalmanovich rushed to fulfill the commandment of rebuke, and we all have something to repent for. However, he did not prove that it is forbidden to pray in public outdoors when necessary. It is clear that no one thought that prayer would be disrupted so blatantly and distressingly.

9. Truth and peace, they loved.

======

Rabbi Yitzhak Neria is the head of Yeshivat Torah B'Zion

0 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

IDF, Conscription Law, Opinion

Anger over revival of conscription law, the shameful decision of the Knesset

The continuation of the controversial draft bill in Israel serves as a slap in the face to soldiers who have been serving since October 7th.

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 13.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Hamas, Hostages, Opinion

Has Bella Hadid gone crazy? 

Bella Hadid glorified Hamas for making a birthday cake for an Israeli hostage that they kidnapped and tortured.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 13.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Hostages

Why Gazan civilians don't reveal the location of Israeli hostages

If Palestinian civilians know where the hostages are, why don't they tell Israel?

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 13.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, IDF, Opinion

The Relentless Spirit: Why wounded Israeli soldiers want to return to the battlefield

Driven by duty, comradeship, and resilience, wounded IDF soldiers are eager to return to the battlefield.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 11.06.24

Israel-Gaza War, Lebanon, Hezbollah

Analysis: Why Israel is putting off going to war with Lebanon

Although Israel desperately wants peace in the North, it has not yet committed to an outright war with Lebanon.

Gila Isaacson, JFeed Staff | 10.06.24

Kindergarten

When Should You Put Your Baby in Kindergarten and How Do You Choose One?

Registration for educational settings for ages birth to three is just around the corner and many parents are asking themselves when is the right time to enroll their baby. So how do you choose the right framework for a child? All the details below.

Noa Leor, PhD | 10.01.24

Celebrations

Sivan Rahav-Meir: How Can Events Be Celebrated These Days?

The news these days are difficult and challenging. Many people are debating how to celebrate their happy events. The Yarchi family, whose son celebrated a Bar Mitzvah, found a unique way to express the joy.

Sivan Rahav-Meir | 19.12.23

'Brothers in Arms'

'Brothers in Arms' for Real and not as a Slogan | Rabbi Shachar Botschak

These days, the same citizens who were in the demonstrations of both sides enter the same tank, the same squad of fighters, and fight for weeks when every moment they are shoulder to shoulder, and their lives depend on each other.

Rabbi Shachar Botschak | 07.12.23

Sivan Rahav-Meir

A Kitchen, a Hotel, and a Tunnel: Three Stories That Really Happened

From the hotel kitchen through Tefillin at the base to the captivity tunnels of Hamas - new chapters of kindness and generosity are being written here,  between man and his Maker and between a man and his friend.

Sivan Rahav-Meir | 29.11.23

Letter to Abigail

An Orphan from the Versailles Disaster in a Letter to Abigail who Lost Her Parents

Limor Zussman, who lost her parents in the Versailles disaster 23 years ago, writes a letter to Abigail Idan, the four-year-old girl who was freed from captivity of the terrorist organization Hamas.

Sivan Rahav-Meir | 28.11.23

"Woe to Us if Not"

Rabbi Hagai Lundin: "Woe to Us if it doesn't Happen in the End"

As ordinary citizens we did not decide whether and how the ceasefire would be conducted. What is left for us these days is to pray and train the muscle of vigilance. It is better not to sit too much in front of the screens now and cuddle with the pictures of the release of the abductees.

Rabbi Hagai Lundin | 27.11.23

The Mixed Feelings

Sivan Rahav-Meir: Happiness Mixed with Frustration, Excitement Mixed with Rage

We have seen so many horror videos, and now - we can see some happy videos. Because even good dreams come true, not just fears and anxieties.

Sivan Rahav-Meir | 26.11.23