Skip to main content
Get our mobile app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Behind the scenes of the election

Beit Shemesh voting fix goes nationwide

After Judge Sohlberg banned ballot-box data sharing, Beit Shemesh's chassidic campaign built a self-reporting system that spread to other cities, while the local Litvish operation stumbled

The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters

United Torah Judaism received 26,858 votes in Beit Shemesh before the double-envelope count, a 35% increase over the previous election and well past the 25,000-vote target set at the start of the campaign. The result came after a day on which the chareidi public turned out in force to fulfill the directive of gedolei Yisrael.

Much of the credit goes to the city’s chassidic campaign headquarters, working closely with Mayor Shmuel Greenberg. Their success came despite internal tensions within the local Degel HaTorah operation, and grew out of a court-driven change in how election headquarters could operate, and a technological solution born in Beit Shemesh that spread to other cities.

A new reality on election day

Ahead of the election, chareidi campaigns faced a major change. Following a decision by Central Elections Committee Chairman Justice Noam Sohlberg, party headquarters could no longer receive information from polling stations about which voters had already cast ballots. Campaign teams that had long relied on this data to target their efforts had to find another way.

At a national meeting of the chassidic campaign, Shimon Goldberg, chairman of the chassidic faction in Beit Shemesh, proposed a solution: rather than relying on data from polling stations, voters would report for themselves that they had voted. The initiative was called “Chapak Hitzba’ati,” or “I voted.”

Goldberg, who worked closely with Mayor Greenberg, guided the project from concept to implementation. Beit Shemesh ran the pilot, and Beitar Illit and Ashdod later joined.

Ready for more?

On election day, blue tents were set up outside the polling stations where chassidic voters cast their ballots. Voters could report by phone, on their mobile devices, with cards bearing one-time codes or by giving their details to Chapak representatives. The data fed into a central control system, displayed on large screens that showed reporting rates by kehillah and neighborhood, down to residential areas within each kehillah. The system was based entirely on voluntary reports, not official data from the polling stations.

Goldberg also recorded a phone message to the chassidic public from his personal number, explaining the change and the importance of self-reporting so that kehillah leaders could focus on those who hadn’t yet reported. A second, urgent message went out as the polls neared closing.

Inside the headquarters

In the main headquarters hall on Sfas Emes Street, more than 150 chassidic kehillah heads and representatives monitored the data and contacted their members. A separate phone operation served chassidim outside the organized kehillos, so that they could be contacted personally as well.

A large volunteer network stood behind this operation. Faction member Yeshaya Weissman worked with shul rabbanim, kollel heads and kehillah leaders to recruit avreichim to volunteer between learning sessions. A dedicated registration system let each volunteer choose his hours, neighborhood and type of activity, so that an avreich learning in the morning could help in the afternoon or evening, and those with cars could join the transportation network.

Degel HaTorah headquarters in Beit Shemesh
Degel HaTorah headquarters in Beit Shemesh
Degel HaTorah headquarters in Beit Shemesh
Degel HaTorah headquarters in Beit Shemesh

The Beit Shemesh chassidic headquarters was the first in the country to open this campaign, beginning with 14 signage distribution centers across the city even before its official launch. The campaign was led by Goldberg along with faction members Weissman and Avraham Nachman Frenkel, as part of the year-round partnership between Shlomei Emunim and Belz. Tzvi Frenkel established and managed the headquarters.

Visitors throughout the day included MK Meir Porush, MK Yisrael Eichler, MK Yitzchak Pindrus, UTJ chairman MK Rabbi Yaakov Asher, Mayor Greenberg and Elyakim Stark, who were briefed on the reporting system. In the evening, Porush went from table to table, reviewing the data and remaining tasks with kehillah representatives.

Rain made work difficult at the reporting stations, and staff had to complete verifications through kehillah heads. When the polls closed, the operation wound down after a long day in which kehillah heads, gabbaim and volunteers worked for hours, many entirely as volunteers.

Disappointment on the Litvish side

While the chassidic headquarters celebrated, the Litvish headquarters was left disappointed, hampered by internal disputes among local representatives and what appeared to be a lack of professional organization.

Even so, and despite Degel HaTorah’s apparent decline locally and the rise of Chomas Toras Yisrael, a breakdown of the data at headquarters shows that the joint effort with Mayor Greenberg added about 6,500 votes for UTJ in Beit Shemesh compared with the previous election. The headquarters attributed the gain to the close cooperation between Greenberg and Goldberg.

A senior figure in the local Degel HaTorah told Kikar HaShabbat: “We worked quite hard. The problem is that we started late, and the results were very disappointing. As part of the activity, the city was divided into 13 action zones, and an extensive voter transportation network was operated to ensure maximum turnout across the city. That didn’t happen in the end, and the votes weren’t fully utilized. Now our hope is for repeat elections, when we’ll know how to draw lessons and maximize our strength.”

The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters
The Beit Shemesh campaign headquarters (Photo: Shlomi Elisha)
Ready for more?

Join our newsletter to receive updates on new articles and exclusive content.

We respect your privacy and will never share your information.

Enjoyed this article?

Yes
No
Follow Us:

Unmissable content


Loading comments...

Also of Interest