Breaking
VP Vance Breaks with Israel, GOP on Antisemitism
Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli Government, and the Republican Party are typically in agreement that the automatic criticism of Israel worldwide stems from antisemitism. A Monday night tweet from VP Vance broke from that stance and drew Israeli ire.
US Vice President J.D. Vance sparked controversy overnight after publicly distancing himself from Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s longstanding assertion that anti-Israel sentiment is inherently antisemitic, exposing growing ideological fault lines within the American right.
In a post on X, Vance wrote that “there’s a difference between not liking Israel (or disagreeing with a given Israeli policy) and antisemitism,” directly contradicting Netanyahu’s repeated position that anti-Israel activism represents a modern expression of antisemitism. Netanyahu has advanced that view frequently during the war, including after the arson attack on a synagogue in Australia, arguing that hostility toward Israel cannot be separated from hatred of Jews.
Vance’s remarks were made in response to a broader online discussion about antisemitism in the United States and reports suggesting that younger American conservatives are becoming less supportive of Israel. While emphasizing that antisemitism remains a serious problem, the vice president argued that opposition to Israeli policies should not automatically be classified as hatred of Jews.
In the same exchange, Vance also claimed that the rise of antisemitism in the US is driven in part by demographic change, a comment that drew criticism and intensified debate around his broader framing of the issue.
The comments are notable given Vance’s role in the current administration and his status as a leading contender to succeed President Donald Trump as the Republican nominee in 2028. Vance has generally expressed support for Israel and condemned Islamist terrorism, but he is also identified with the party’s more isolationist wing, which favors reducing US involvement abroad and questions long-standing foreign policy commitments.
His statement comes amid an expanding rift within the American conservative movement over Israel, antisemitism, and US foreign policy. High-profile figures on the right, including Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens, Marjorie Taylor Greene, and Nick Fuentes, have increasingly voiced anti-Israel views, at times crossing into overtly antisemitic rhetoric. At the same time, pro-Israel conservatives continue to hold significant influence within the administration and Republican leadership.
Vance’s attempt to draw a clear distinction between criticism of Israel and antisemitism reflects that internal struggle, and places him publicly at odds with Netanyahu on a question that has become central to Israel’s diplomatic messaging.