Former Netanyahu Public Diplomacy Chief Argues Against a Broad Ground Offensive Now

Ran Baratz says it would be a mistake to launch a broad ground offensive in Gaza now, with Hamas and Iran setting the timetable: "They will all pay in full. But under conditions we force, not vice versa."

"They will all pay in full. But under conditions we force, not vice versa." (Photo: Haim Goldberg, Flash90)

Ran Baratz, former Head of Public Diplomacy for Netanyahu and one of the right's most prominent commentators, says it would be a mistake to launch a broad ground offensive in Gaza now, with Hamas and Iran dictating the timetable.

In a post put up on social media, Baratz wrote: "I am silent and wondering, wondering and silent. But in the end I have to say, and I know this isn't the public attitude, but it is my duty: It would be incorrect to launch a broad ground offensive in Gaza at present."

Baratz explained that "The Iranians are not stupid. They were ready for and are expecting this response, while we are in a major intelligence fog. The danger that this is a multi-front trap is high. We mustn't underestimate the enemy. The goal right now needs to be to stabilize the situation and the borders. This is much more urgent, because all the sectors are heating up."

He added that "We also need to understand how and what we didn't see. We learned that there a lot of blind spots regarding the enemy which we thought we knew almost everything about. This is a dangerous situation. Vengeance will come. The price will be paid. It is a historic duty. There's no debate or discussion. And of course will exact a maximal cost in the meantime, but not in territorial occupation. Not in the conditions they (the Iranians) are forcing on us and which they built and prepared for a long time, while we were in the dark."


Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

Judea and Samaria, Terrorism

Two killed in shooting attack at gas station near Eli

Two people were killed in a shooting attack at a gas station near Eli. The terrorist was reportedly neutralized on site. Security forces are searching for additional suspects.

JFeed Staff | 17:04

IDF, IDF Rabbinate

IDF Chief Rabbinate Search Unit goes from searching for hostages to holding the line in Judea and Samaria

The IDF Rabbinate is helping to fill holes in an army stretched everywhere.

JFeed Staff | 14:01

Israel-Gaza War, Humanitarian Aid

Dozens killed and wounded while looting aid trucks in Gaza

A Gazan mob descended on aid trucks in the northern Gaza Strip, and many were trampled on or run over. In addition, the IDF fired in the direction of part of the mob moving towards them.

Arye Yoeli, JFeed Staff | 13:13

Israel-Gaza War, UAE

UAE joins airdropping of aid into Gaza Strip

The UAE Defense Ministry announced it was joining a multinational effort to airdrop aid to directly reach Gazan civilians in need.

Avi Woolf | 12:31

Hezbollah, Targeted Assassination

Targeted assassination in Syria: Hezbollah vehicle in flames after drone strike

A Hezbollah vehicle was struck by an Israeli drone, killing one.

JFeed Staff | 11:08

Israel-Gaza War, New Zealand

Victory for Israeli PR: Another country to label Hamas as a terrorist organization

The government in New Zealand has placed Hamas on its terror list. "The attacks on October 7 shattered the idea that the political and military arms of Hamas could be separated."

Michal Yoskovich, Jfeed Staff | 10:23

IDF, Charedim

Gantz to Gallant: "All Israeli society needs to serve"

Minister Benny Gantz responded to Defense Minister Yoav Gallant's insistence that a draft law must be supported by all members of the coalition - including the State Camp party.

JFeed Staff | 28.02.24

Israel-Gaza War

Is Hamas losing control of the southern Gaza Strip?

Gazans in the Rafah protesting merchants selling humanitarian aid - and Hamas couldn't punish either.

Yair Amar, JFeed Staff | 28.02.24

IDF, Charedim, Israel-Gaza War

Gallant: Everyone needs to shoulder the burden

The Defense Minister addressed the question of drafting Charedim, stating that "the challenges we face prove: everyone has to carry the burden, all parts of the nation."

Liran Vainshtain, JFeed Staff | 28.02.24

Israel-Gaza War, Kiryat Shmonah

IDF strikes launchers that fired on Kiryat Shmonah

IDF fighter planes struck a launcher which fired on Kiryat Shmonah this morning and also attacked terrorist infrastructure in southern Lebanon. Watch:

JFeed Staff | 28.02.24

Israel-Gaza War, Associated Press, Reuters

Victims of October 7 massacre sue AP and Reuters for 2.5 million NIS in Jerusalem District Court

The families of five victims of October 7 are suing AP and Reuters for the alleged participation of their employees in the massacre.

Avi Woolf | 28.02.24

Israel-Gaza War, PTSD

IDF opens new mental health center to help provide rapid treatment for battle trauma

According to the IDF, some 85% of soldiers who needed treatment for battle response ended up being fit to return to their units.

Avi Woolf | 28.02.24