Report Exposes Israel's Hidden Vulnerability: One-Third Left Unprotected from Missiles

Israel's State Comptroller Matanyahu Englman has issued a scathing report exposing systemic failures in the country's preparedness for aerial threats, revealing that approximately one-third of Israelis are not adequately shielded from rocket fire despite years of warnings and the brutal reality of the ongoing war against Hamas terrorists. The audit, which examined dozens of local authorities, government ministries, and critical infrastructure, paints a grim picture of neglect that persisted even after the October 7, 2023, Hamas massacre and the subsequent barrage of over 26,000 rockets and missiles from Gaza, Lebanon, Yemen, and Iran through October 2024.

In cities like Ashkelon, Givatayim, Holon, and Gilboa, public shelters were found in deplorable condition, with rusty doors, poor lighting, blocked escape routes, leaks, and missing signage, rendering them useless in emergencies. The report highlighted that more than half of hospital beds in high-risk areas lacked proper shielding, while operating rooms, catheterization labs, and intensive care units remained dangerously exposed. Only 17% of catheterization rooms met required protection standards, leaving medical staff and patients vulnerable during rocket alerts.

Mental health support fared no better. Resilience centers struggled to meet demand for trauma treatment, and the Ministry of Health failed to establish a reinforced system, resulting in only partial care for affected children and victims. Education systems also faltered, with inadequate protocols for remote learning and psychological support during prolonged rocket barrages.

Englman criticized the Defense Ministry, IDF, and National Security Council for failing to correct five major deficiencies identified in a 2020 audit, leaving critical facilities unmapped and without multi-year fortification plans. Even after the war began and aerial threats materialized, efforts were limited to "a few spot actions," with no comprehensive strategy or budget allocation. The report warned that without immediate reforms, including mapping vital sites, clarifying responsibilities, and securing funding, Israel's resilience remains compromised.

This audit comes amid the war's heavy toll: 700 IDF soldiers killed defending against Hamas rockets, endless alerts disrupting daily life, and communities still haunted by the October 7 atrocities. The findings demand urgent action to protect civilians from future barrages, ensuring shelters, hospitals, and schools are ready when terrorists strike again.