Bassem Youssef's "Two Faces" Controversy: The Clip Sparking Accusations of Duplicity

In a viral clip that's ignited a firestorm across social media, Egyptian-American comedian and activist Bassem Youssef has been accused of tailoring his message on Hamas and Israel to his audience, praising the terrorist group as "resistance" on Arabic TV while allegedly "tricking" British host Piers Morgan into a platform for anti-Israel rants by feigning agreement on Hamas's status.

The post was shared by prominent Arab-Christian commentator Brother Rachid (@BrotherRasheed).

Rachid is a former Muslim turned Christian advocate and terrorism expert known for his Arabic-language critiques of extremism, includes a 2.5-minute video excerpt from Youssef's appearance on Egyptian channel ON E (a pro-government outlet).

In the clip, subtitled in English, Youssef boasts about his strategy during two explosive interviews with Morgan on Piers Morgan Uncensored in late 2024. "I said Hamas is a terrorist organization—not because I believe it, but because it allowed me to have two hours to attack Israel," Youssef tells the Egyptian host, laughing. "If I didn’t say that, they wouldn’t have let me continue."

He frames it as savvy activism: a tactical concession to Western "gatekeepers" to amplify Palestinian voices. Rachid's caption drives the point home: "Bassem Youssef delivers two different messages, one for the West and another for the Middle East."

The Backstory: Youssef vs. Morgan - A Clash Heard 'Round the World

Bassem Youssef, 50, rose to fame as Egypt's "Jon Stewart" with his satirical show El Bernameg, which lampooned the Muslim Brotherhood and military regimes during the Arab Spring, earning him a TED Talk and a 2014 Time "100 Most Influential" nod. Exiled after backlash from his government critiques, he moved to the U.S., pivoting to stand-up and commentary.

Post-October 7, 2023 (Hamas's attack killing 1,200 Israelis), Youssef became a fierce pro-Palestinian voice, amassing 1.2 million X followers with viral takedowns of Israeli policies.His fireworks with Piers Morgan erupted in November 2024 during a heated Uncensored debate. Youssef called Israel's Gaza operations a "genocide," accused the IDF of "Nazi-like" tactics, and defended Palestinian resistance, prompting Morgan to cut him off repeatedly, labeling him a "Hamas apologist."

A follow-up in December devolved into shouting matches, with Youssef equating Israeli settlers to "terrorists" and Morgan retorting that Youssef was "whitewashing" Hamas's atrocities. Clips from those episodes exploded, viewed over 100 million times combined, turning Youssef into a hero for Arab audiences and a villain for pro-Israel ones.

The Egyptian TV revelation, from an October 27, 2025, episode of Ma'a Kelshi on ON E, flips the script. Youssef, appearing relaxed in a casual interview, admits to the "trick": By briefly calling Hamas a "terrorist organization" early in the Morgan exchanges, he bought time to pivot into broader critiques of Israeli "occupation" and U.S. complicity.

"In the West, they control the narrative," he says in the clip. "You have to play their game to get your point across." He doubles down on his true stance: Hamas as "freedom fighters" resisting apartheid, not terrorists.

Rachid's Angle: A Voice Against Extremism

Brother Rachid (real name Rachid, a pseudonym for safety) is no stranger to controversy. The Moroccan-born ex-Muslim, now a U.S.-based TV host of Daring Question (a satellite program reaching 100 million Arabs), converted to Christianity in the 1990s after a personal crisis. He's built a following of 500,000+ on X by debunking Islamist narratives, advocating for apostasy rights, and calling out antisemitism in Arab media. His 2013 Al Jazeera appearance, where he debated Islam live, drew death threats, forcing him into exile.

This isn't isolated. Youssef's faced similar scrutiny: A 2024 New York Times profile noted his "nuanced" Hamas views, while Egyptian authorities once banned him for "insulting" the Prophet. The clip revives debates on "asymmetric messaging" in the Israel-Palestine discourse, where advocates like Youssef (or Norman Finkelstein) accuse Western outlets of pro-Israel bias, forcing rhetorical jujitsu.

Morgan hasn't responded yet, but if history's a guide, expect a fiery Uncensored rebuttal.