Opinion

I thought a Lebanon invasion was a mistake - here's why I changed my mind

Part of great statesmanship is exploiting opportunities, even when not fully ready or prepared. This is the case with the IDF and Hezbollah at the current moment.

Israel vs. Hezbollah. (Photo: BERK CAN/Shutterstock)

Just a few months, I wrote that I don't think it's right to enter into a full-scale war in Lebanon, and that it would be better to delay it for a few years. But a large part of good statesmanship is knowing how to spot opportunities, and the State of Israel has created a rare opportunity to fundamentally change the reality on the ground in the last two weeks.

True, it's not like there isn't any Hezbollah left to fight or that entering into Lebanon will be a walk in the park. It will be costly. But in the last few weeks, Hezbollah has suffered hundreds of dead and thousands of wounded, its senior command has ceased to exist, its media network has collapsed, it has lost significant amounts of weapons, and its morale is at a low point.

In addition, it turns out that it hasn't really succeeded in carrying out one of its main threats: paralyzing Israel with massive rocket salvos on ports, power stations, and major population centers in the Haifa and Dan Bloc areas. Most of what Hezbollah has succeeded in doing is firing short-range rockets on the Galilee - but this is precisely the sort of threat which a ground invasion of Lebanon can almost entirely remove.

Therefore, what I propose to do is evacuate the Lebanese population south of the Litani (perhaps aside from Christian villages hostile to Hezbollah), occupy southern Lebanon, establish a defensive line along the Litani, and announce that Israel will only withdraw from the territory in exchange for full peace with Lebanon.

Who knows, maybe some Lebanese Sadat with Saudi/American/French backing will arise after Hezbollah is shattered. Or maybe not.

Either way, both options are far preferable than passive defense along the border and letting Hezbollah rebuild itself.

Elad Nahshon is a PhD student at Bar Ilan University, studying the political and social history of Zionism and the State of Israel.

1 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

1
A million per cent yes.
Annonymous 30.09.24

War in Lebanon, Fallen Soldier

Cleared for publication: Staff Sergeant Nazar Itkin fell in battle in Lebanon 

Avi Nachmani, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Commando Units, Lebanon

First look at commandos in action in Lebanon | WATCH

Avi Nachmani, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

IDF, War in Lebanon, 36th Division

IDF expands its Lebanon offensive with another division

Avi Nachmani | 02.10.24

War in Lebanon, Fallen Soldier

Captain Eitan Oster- fallen hero of the Egoz unit

Avi Nachmani, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Iran attack, Ballistic missiles, Israel at war

With trembling hands: more uncovered details about the Iranian attack

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Rocket interception, Iran attack, Ballistic missiles, Israel under fire

These are the countries that helped Israel intercept the Iranian attack

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Hod Hasharon, Iran attack, Israel at war, Ballistic missiles fired

Damage Revealed: Approximately 100 Homes in Hod Hasharon Affected by Iranian Attack

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Israeli retaliation, Iran missile attack

The end of Iran? Report: This is how the Israeli attack will be carried out

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Halevi response, Iran attack, Israel at war, IDF Chief of Staff

Chief of Staff After Situation Assessment: "We Will Choose When to Exact the Price"

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Hezbollah war, Israel in Lebanon, IDF ground operation

First Step on Hezbollah Soil: Documentation of the Entry of Division 98 into Lebanon

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Iran Attack, statistic, Israeli defence, Iron dome, interceptions

The shocking summary of the Iran attack: 1,864 Sirens, 2 Lightly Injured by Shrapnel

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Netanyahu Cabinet meeting, Israeli PM response, Iranian attack

Netanyahu's pointed response to the Iran attack on Israel

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24
JFeed App Icon
Get the app JFeed