Hamas, Israel-Gaza War

Is Hamas winning the war in Gaza?

At this point, Hamas have proved that even though they are down, they are not quite 'out'.

Khan Yunis (Photo: Shutterstock / Anas-Mohammed)

Nearly a year after the October 7 attack on Israel, Hamas leader Khaled Mashaal claims the terrorist organization is "winning the war" despite heavy losses.

In an op-ed for Arutz Sheva, Jonathan S. Tobin explains the truth behind their claim. Here's what he says:

Hamas's Strategy: Survival as Success

Hamas appears to be banking on a simple yet potentially effective strategy: survival. The group believes that merely remaining operational at the war's conclusion will constitute a victory.

They are playing a waiting game, anticipating that international pressure will eventually force Israel to leave Gaza. Their leaders argue that their movement is an "idea" that can't be militarily defeated.

The Role of International Politics

A significant aspect of Hamas's confidence stems from developments in U.S. politics: Although Israel had strong U.S. support at the beginning of the war, that has gradually shifted. This is partially a result of pressure from left-wing groups and concerns about what supporting Israel will mean for the 2024 elections.

Military Reality vs. Political Perception

Despite Hamas's claims, the military situation on the ground tells a different story: Hamas has suffered severe losses, with an estimated 17,000 operatives killed. Its organized military formations are no longer considered combat-effective and its ability to launch long-range missiles into Israel has been significantly degraded. However, Hamas believes that these military setbacks can be overcome if they maintain political relevance and support among Palestinians.

The Palestinian Political Landscape

Hamas is banking on a long-standing pattern in Palestinian politics where groups gain credibility through conflict with Israel. They anticipate increased support in both Gaza and the West Bank and they also believe that they could replace the Palestinian Authority (currently led by Fatah).

Challenges for Israel

Israel faces several obstacles in its goal to eliminate Hamas. These include International pressure to limit civilian casualties and end the conflict, internal strife and protests, particularly from families of hostages and the complex nature of urban warfare in Gaza.

Whether Hamas is "winning" depends largely on one's definition of victory. While they've suffered significant military losses, their survival and potential for political gains keep their aspirations alive. As the situation continues to evolve, it's clear that both sides face significant challenges and that the definition of "victory" in this conflict remains hotly contested.

1 Comments

Do not send comments that include inflammatory words, defamation, and content that exceeds the limit of good taste.

1
They're still around. But the pressure continues.
The Jewish Patriarch 19.09.24

IDF, War in Lebanon, 36th Division

IDF expands its Lebanon offensive with another division

Avi Nachmani | 02.10.24

Iran attack, Ballistic missiles, Israel at war

With trembling hands: more uncovered details about the Iranian attack

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Rocket interception, Iran attack, Ballistic missiles, Israel under fire

These are the countries that helped Israel intercept the Iranian attack

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Hod Hasharon, Iran attack, Israel at war, Ballistic missiles fired

Damage Revealed: Approximately 100 Homes in Hod Hasharon Affected by Iranian Attack

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Israeli retaliation, Iran missile attack

The end of Iran? Report: This is how the Israeli attack will be carried out

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 02.10.24

Halevi response, Iran attack, Israel at war, IDF Chief of Staff

Chief of Staff After Situation Assessment: "We Will Choose When to Exact the Price"

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Hezbollah war, Israel in Lebanon, IDF ground operation

First Step on Hezbollah Soil: Documentation of the Entry of Division 98 into Lebanon

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Iran Attack, statistic, Israeli defence, Iron dome, interceptions

The shocking summary of the Iran attack: 1,864 Sirens, 2 Lightly Injured by Shrapnel

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

Netanyahu Cabinet meeting, Israeli PM response, Iranian attack

Netanyahu's pointed response to the Iran attack on Israel

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24

IDF Spokesperson, Iran attack, Hagari response

IDF Spokesman: Israel Will 'Continue Strong Strikes in the Mideast' Tonight

Eliana Fleming | 01.10.24

Jake Sullivan, US reaction to Iran attack, Hezbollah rockets

US Condemns Iran's Attack on Israel as a Major Escalation

Eliana Fleming | 01.10.24

Khamenei, Iranian attack,  Hezbollah missiles, Israel response

Iran is already shaking: Ali Khamenei's step

Eliana Fleming, JFeed Staff | 01.10.24
JFeed App Icon
Get the app JFeed