Death By Vote
40% of NY Jews Want to Die - Should we stop them?
As I wrote earlier today the Jewish complex of freedom which manifests in an over-indulgence of breaking civilizational norms much due to a mix of hyper-intellect, historical trauma, and deeply rooted theological currents - leads the jews to lose their independence time and time again.
it seems that the case of Mamdani-Jews symbolizes this problem well.
A joke circulates that even if a scarecrow runs at the head of the Democratic Party, Jews will vote for that same scarecrow. There is an even more aggressive version of this joke, which claims that even if a Nazi runs at the head of the Democratic Party, Jews will vote for him.
Well, Zohran Mamdani, who just claimed that Muslims were the true victims of September 11, is about to be elected mayor of New York City.
In principle, one should learn from Moses, our teacher, that even when a nation or a group commits the most terrible and severe sins, they still deserve mercy, and one can have compassion for them. I’m referring to the episode of the Golden Calf, where Moses saves Israel, but not before sending the Tribe of Levi to kill three thousand of the idol worshipers.
The question is, what happens when 40 percent of a certain community wants to bring about a situation where 100 percent of the members of a certain community face danger?
If those 40 percent of Jews desire Judeo-suicide, should we
Regarding the rescue attempt, due to the Holocaust complex and paranoia that American Judaism has adopted as its own, (without a normative reason to do so, it should be noted), it seems that at this stage it will be difficult to cure American Jews from imagining Hitler or Stalin everywhere. The rising antisemitism in the American right certainly does not help this either. So a cure for the core "reason", which is in fact a pavlovian impulse, which makes Jews run to the hands of the most non-liberal liberals, will never be invented sadly.
Jews, especially those on the left, often use politics as a coping mechanism for this paranoia-turned-identity issue. And since stupid problems lead to stupid solutions, this spillover, manifesting in the choice of Muslims or Progressives as proxies to save them from mostly-imagined American-Nazism, continues to endanger real lives and, sadly, it will likely persist.
If Mamdani becomes mayor, we will see attacks against Jews rise, as happened during the de Blasio period, and therefore the attempt to save those 40% who brought this upon all us will involve a degree of self-endangerment for the the non-complacent non-suicidal ones.
Furthermore, the attempt to save the suicidal leftist jews is essentially an attempt to save people who support a candidate funded by the Muslim Brotherhood, and therefore those Jews, whether we recognize it or not, are enemies of the Jewish and American collective, and the attempt to save them will harm the Jewish and American collective.
Regarding their separation from the Jewish community? One of the central stories of the Jewish community is, at least in the last century, the Zionist story. Like the story of European Jewry in the Holocaust, it has become part of the American Jewish narrative.
If Zionism has taught us anything, it is that there is some physical value in Jewish sovereignty because it means jews are not dependening on the mercies of foreigners.
Hence why too much AIPAC is a bad idea for us as Jews who want to be self-sufficient.
Back to the issue, it may be that the primary need here is to separate between supporters of Mamdani and other suicidal Jews (perhaps Jewish-jihadis?), and between Jews who aspire to have self-sovereignty at least in the communal sense in which they are interested in continuing to survive without the need to transform everyone around them - or kill their own identity.
The separation here, between Jews who want to survive, and Jews who want to disappear and who encourage the rest of the Jews (and non-Jews) to disappear by force (socialism) - must be made.
On a wider level one can argue socialism is not only made to bring forth the disappearing of jews, but of all nations, and that is exactly where the jews are just a very enhanced cersion of this microcosmos of the logical structure of socialism as a whole; given the fact that many of the "greatest" socialist thinkers are jewish, one can think of socialism also as a Jewish movement for national self-annihilation, which in an equal way plagues Jews just like any other nation infested by it. Yes, one can admit that without being a Nazi.
One may say that Marxism is Gnostic, but it carries the motivations of secularized Judaism, expressed in the attempt to sacrifice oneself for a new faith. This new-religion is, in essence, a secularized form of Pauline Christianity, created by secularized Jews or Ex-Jews, who seek to save the entire world by sacrificing themselves, their Judaism, and the Judaism of their fellow Jews, in the belief that if the Jew gives up his god, anyone else must follow, but that while doing so, they believe they are also transforming and redeeming the world in a process of De-Judaizing, that is meant to make them appear almost christ-like.
Hence, Jewish socialists manifest a renunciation not only of human freedom, but also of the Jew’s freedom in his attempt to be human or to be Non-Pauline.
At the same time, it is a renunciation of the individual’s self-sovereignty, in favor of a unifying vision in which there is room neither for Judaism itself nor for any form of thought that is not collective. It is difficult to claim that this virus came solely from Gnosticism, since its motivation is messianic, containing elements of the Second Temple period or early Christianity. Therefore, our distancing from that candidate is also a distancing from the virus and from our own inner demons, and it is a call for a Jewish soul-searching.
Therefore, it seems that the time has come to create some separation between Jews who want to survive and Jews who seek to cancel their own Jewishness, and also politically push for socialism which will lead to communism that will force Jews to cancel their Judaism publicly, and ultimately their Zionism, that is, their desire for sovereignty and survival.
The question is, is there any Jewish leader with the courage wisdom or balls to say these things?